←back to thread

473 points Brajeshwar | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.281s | source
Show context
CGMthrowaway ◴[] No.46219027[source]
There was a study published about how much air pollution dropped in NYC during the COVID lockdown. PM2.5 was found to have dropped 36%. However with more robust analysis, this drop was discovered to not be statistically significant. I would caution anyone reading this who is tempted by confirmation bias.

Source: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7314691/

replies(4): >>46219356 #>>46219489 #>>46219984 #>>46220609 #
1. graeme ◴[] No.46219984[source]
"Not statistically significant" doesn't mean did not happen.

Given the physical mechanisms involved it is implausible that pollution did not decline. And if you look at their data you see a marked drop in 2020 at day 70

This is March 10 or thereabouts, I think. And there are ZERO high pm 2.5 days for a 20 day stretch or so. This isn't seen in other years. The vast bulk of days are below the trend.

And then for the rest of the year there are some days above the trend line but no high pm 2.5 days.

This fits with people being extra cautious in the early days and then relaxing a bit as things went on.

Now, I'm eyeballing this so I could be incorrect. But:

1. The effect was found in other cities

2. The physical mechanism makes it highly expected that there would be a drop

The study was about the slope of the regression modal, but if you had scrambled the years I'm fairly confident I could have picked 2020 out of the set.