←back to thread

208 points mohi-kalantari | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.209s | source
Show context
charcircuit ◴[] No.46195181[source]
>But in reality, Samsung (and the other Android OEMs) cannot compete with Google and its unique control over hardware and software.

Yes, they can. We are talking about applying provided security patches to source code, and then releasing a new version of their OS. For patches that have existed for months. The time from patch to release should be on the order l of days from receiving the patches to having a validated OS release with the fix being sent to users. It's not the control of Android which makes Google possible to patch their Pixel branch of AOSP faster than Samsung can patch their own. It's that Samsung doesn't care about prompt security fixes so they don't allocate engineers to do the work.

replies(2): >>46195681 #>>46195907 #
kwanbix ◴[] No.46195681[source]
The problem is that each OEM releases 50 different models per year, vs Google (or Apple) that release 3 or 4 models.
replies(8): >>46195780 #>>46195961 #>>46196041 #>>46196054 #>>46196062 #>>46196127 #>>46196192 #>>46196240 #
TheDong ◴[] No.46196054[source]
Weird how LineageOS supports ~300 devices while still managing to release patches.

I bet this CVE's patched quicker on a samsung device running LineageOS than the stock OS.

The real difference is that Google has a more competent software development process and release process than other android OEMs, regardless of how many different devices they have.

replies(1): >>46196079 #
1. stackskipton ◴[] No.46196079[source]
LineageOS doesn't customize the hell out of their OSes per device.

That's core of the issue. Samsung takes Android, customizes per device and then tosses them into the world. So now they don't have 1 OS to update, they have 100s of OSes to update.