←back to thread

549 points thecr0w | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
thuttinger ◴[] No.46184466[source]
Claude/LLMs in general are still pretty bad at the intricate details of layouts and visual things. There are a lot of problems that are easy to get right for a junior web dev but impossible for an LLM. On the other hand, I was able to write a C program that added gamma color profile support to linux compositors that don't support it (in my case Hyprland) within a few minutes! A - for me - seemingly hard task, which would have taken me at least a day or more if I didn't let Claude write the code. With one prompt Claude generated C code that compiled on first try that:

- Read an .icc file from disk

- parsed the file and extracted the VCGT (video card gamma table)

- wrote the VCGT to the video card for a specified display via amdgpu driver APIs

The only thing I had to fix was the ICC parsing, where it would parse header strings in the wrong byte-order (they are big-endian).

replies(3): >>46184840 #>>46185379 #>>46185476 #
jacquesm ◴[] No.46185379[source]
Claude didn't write that code. Someone else did and Claude took that code without credit to the original author(s), adapted it to your use case and then presented it as its own creation to you and you accepted this. If a human did this we probably would have a word for them.
replies(16): >>46185404 #>>46185408 #>>46185442 #>>46185473 #>>46185478 #>>46185791 #>>46185885 #>>46185911 #>>46186086 #>>46186326 #>>46186420 #>>46186759 #>>46187004 #>>46187058 #>>46187235 #>>46188771 #
bsaul ◴[] No.46185478[source]
That's an interesting hypothesis : that LLM are fundamentally unable to produce original code.

Do you have papers to back this up ? That was also my reaction when i saw some really crazy accurate comments on some vibe coded piece of code, but i couldn't prove it, and thinking about it now i think my intuition was wrong (ie : LLMs do produce original complex code).

replies(7): >>46185592 #>>46185822 #>>46186708 #>>46187030 #>>46187456 #>>46188840 #>>46191020 #
moron4hire ◴[] No.46187456[source]
No, the thing needing proof is the novel idea: that LLMs can produce original code.
replies(3): >>46187777 #>>46188015 #>>46194023 #
1. ChromaticPanic ◴[] No.46194023[source]
This just reeks of a lack of understanding of how transformers work. Unlike Markov Chains that can only regurgitate known sequences, transformers can actually make new combinations.