←back to thread

62 points grouchy | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.397s | source
Show context
averynicepen ◴[] No.46178945[source]
I bristled at the title, article contents, and their spreadsheet example, but this does actually touch on a real paint point that I have had - how do you enable power users to learn more powerful tools already present in the software? By corollary, how do you turn more casual users into power users?

I do a lot of CAD. Every single keyboard shortcut I know was learned only because I needed to do something that was either *highly repetitive* or *highly frustrating*, leading me to dig into Google and find the fast way to do it.

However, everything that is only moderately repetitive/frustrating and below is still being done the simple way. And I've used these programs for years.

I have always dreamed of user interfaces having competent, contextual user tutorials that space out learning about advanced and useful features over the entire duration that you use. Video games do this process well, having long since replaced singular "tutorial sections" with a stepped gameplay mechanic rollout that gradually teaches people incredibly complex game mechanics over time.

A simple example to counter the auto-configuration interpretation most of the other commenters are thinking of. In a toolbar dropdown, highlight all the features I already know how to use regularly. When you detect me trying to learn a new feature, help me find it, highlight it in a "currently learning" color, and slowly change the highlight color to "learned" in proportion to my muscle memory.

replies(5): >>46178978 #>>46179098 #>>46179122 #>>46179303 #>>46187448 #
cheschire ◴[] No.46178978[source]
I break out blender every six months or so in order to create a model for 3d printing. It needs to be precise and often has threads or other repetitive structures.

Every. Single. Time. I spend at least the first 3 hours relearning how to use all the tools again with Claude reminding me where modifiers are, and which modifier allows what. And which hotkey slices. Etc etc.

replies(1): >>46187466 #
grouchy ◴[] No.46187466[source]
I guess what if you had Claude in the app, and it didn't just tell you what to do, it could even surface ephemeral UI for each task?

This is really what generative UI would enable.

replies(1): >>46187498 #
1. cheschire ◴[] No.46187498[source]
yeah but when you then need to do the same action 4 times in a row, getting claude to provide the correct action all 4 times takes a lot more brainpower on my part than just learning the menus yet again, right?