←back to thread

504 points puttycat | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
theoldgreybeard ◴[] No.46182214[source]
If a carpenter builds a crappy shelf “because” his power tools are not calibrated correctly - that’s a crappy carpenter, not a crappy tool.

If a scientist uses an LLM to write a paper with fabricated citations - that’s a crappy scientist.

AI is not the problem, laziness and negligence is. There needs to be serious social consequences to this kind of thing, otherwise we are tacitly endorsing it.

replies(37): >>46182289 #>>46182330 #>>46182334 #>>46182385 #>>46182388 #>>46182401 #>>46182463 #>>46182527 #>>46182613 #>>46182714 #>>46182766 #>>46182839 #>>46182944 #>>46183118 #>>46183119 #>>46183265 #>>46183341 #>>46183343 #>>46183387 #>>46183435 #>>46183436 #>>46183490 #>>46183571 #>>46183613 #>>46183846 #>>46183911 #>>46183917 #>>46183923 #>>46183940 #>>46184450 #>>46184551 #>>46184653 #>>46184796 #>>46185025 #>>46185817 #>>46185849 #>>46189343 #
kklisura ◴[] No.46183387[source]
> AI is not the problem, laziness and negligence is

This reminds me about discourse about a gun problem in US, "guns don't kill people, people kill people", etc - it is a discourse used solely for the purpose of not doing anything and not addressing anything about the underlying problem.

So no, you're wrong - AI IS THE PROBLEM.

replies(2): >>46183583 #>>46183639 #
1. sneak ◴[] No.46183639[source]
> it is a discourse used solely for the purpose of not doing anything and not addressing anything about the underlying problem

Solely? Oh brother.

In reality it’s the complete opposite. It exists to highlight the actual source of the problem, as both industries/practitioners using AI professionally and safely, and communities with very high rates of gun ownership and exceptionally low rates of gun violence exist.

It isn’t the tools. It’s the social circumstances of the people with access to the tools. That’s the point. The tools are inanimate. You can use them well or use them badly. The existence of the tools does not make humans act badly.