←back to thread

263 points josephcsible | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
mr_windfrog ◴[] No.46178827[source]
What this incident really shows is the growing gap between how easy it is to create a convincing warning and how costly it is to verify what's actually happening. Hoaxes aren't new, but generative tools make fabrication almost free and massively increase the volume.

The rail operator didn't do anything wrong. After an earthquake and a realistic-looking image, the only responsible action is to treat it as potentially real and inspect the track.

This wasn't catastrophic, but it's a preview of a world where a single person can cheaply trigger high-cost responses. The systems we build will have to adapt, not by ignoring social media reports, but by developing faster, more resilient ways to distinguish signal from noise.

replies(9): >>46178848 #>>46178936 #>>46179699 #>>46180135 #>>46180154 #>>46180642 #>>46180686 #>>46181129 #>>46185243 #
belorn ◴[] No.46180642[source]
Given the number of cctv cameras that operate in the UK, and their continued growth, I am surprised that the rail operator did not have access to a direct view of the bridge. I am also a bit surprised that there isn't technology to detect rail damage, especially the power lines that runs over the track.

Where I live it is not uncommon for rail to have detection for people walking on the rail, and bridges to have extra protection against jumpers. I wouldn't be that surprised if the same system can be used to verify damage.

replies(5): >>46180679 #>>46181516 #>>46181549 #>>46182101 #>>46184118 #
mubou2 ◴[] No.46180679[source]
This is the part that I find insane. What if the bridge had collapsed, and no one had bothered to post a picture of it to social media?
replies(1): >>46181525 #
1. pmyteh ◴[] No.46181525[source]
I mean, you're supposed to call the police or Network Rail: there are placards on the (remains of the) bridge with the telephone number. But yes, it's not uncommon to have to send a train to examine the line (at slow speed, able to stop within line-of-sight) after extreme weather.