←back to thread

430 points mhb | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
delichon ◴[] No.46177641[source]
Back in 2025 before cheap bots, our grandparents endured lives of servitude. They spent an enormous amount of time doing simple chores like folding clothes, driving, programming, washing and dusting, grooming themselves. They had to walk their own dogs and play with their own children. They sometimes even had to cook their own food, directly over fire. "Hygiene" was a primitive joke. A full day's work usually wasn't even enough to buy a single new car. They wrote checks to the government, rather than the other way around. Life was brutal, desperate and short.
replies(6): >>46177748 #>>46179381 #>>46179417 #>>46179665 #>>46180237 #>>46181210 #
djtango ◴[] No.46179665[source]
Why is UBI assumed as part of techtopia? When the government has access to unlimited labour and military via robots, why do they need citizens anymore? Beyond some antiquated moral obligation, why would a government actually do anything for a population that is net value extracting?
replies(7): >>46179726 #>>46179806 #>>46179836 #>>46180763 #>>46181052 #>>46185336 #>>46185480 #
SturgeonsLaw ◴[] No.46179836[source]
>why would a government actually do anything for a population that is net value extracting?

Because we outnumber them a million to one, and history is littered with examples of what happens to leaders who squeeze their population a little too far

replies(5): >>46180006 #>>46180028 #>>46180032 #>>46180628 #>>46182130 #
bigstrat2003 ◴[] No.46180006[source]
I'm not really convinced it's actually possible to overthrow a modern government. The disparity in killing power available to the two sides is just too great. Like yeah we outnumber the government a million to one (figuratively), but that's not going to help much when they have tanks, artillery, and planes to defend themselves with.
replies(5): >>46180033 #>>46180685 #>>46181006 #>>46182629 #>>46185546 #
1. beeflet ◴[] No.46180685{3}[source]
The highly specialized vehicles of war are not that threatening in a civil conflict. Think about how much tax money it takes to purchase a tank for example. There is maybe 1 tank for every 1000 people, let's say. Yet it only takes a single rocket launcher to destroy a tank.

Look at what happened to the USA in Afganistan recently. What really threatens the chances of popular revolution are the systems of surveillance and inter-dependence that we are building up, and the existence of killer drones that can compete with armed peasants at scale.