Most active commenters
  • MarkMarine(3)

←back to thread

Autism's confusing cousins

(www.psychiatrymargins.com)
350 points Anon84 | 11 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source | bottom
1. elif ◴[] No.46173264[source]
Based on what I've read lately, my consensus perspective is that 80% of what people consider autism is actually just the western diet's effect on normal brain chemistry.
replies(4): >>46173314 #>>46175809 #>>46175980 #>>46187243 #
2. MarkMarine ◴[] No.46173314[source]
[flagged]
replies(2): >>46173403 #>>46187250 #
3. tiborsaas ◴[] No.46173403[source]
You should also think before you call people stupid. If you google autism test, you'll find this:

https://www.clinical-partners.co.uk/for-adults/autism-and-as...

"I prefer to do things on my own, rather than with others."

"I prefer doing things the same way - for instance my morning routine or trip to the supermarket"

"I find myself becoming strongly absorbed in something – even obsessional"

These are all questions everybody living in a modern society can relate to.

Of course autism is a real condition, but modern society somewhat requires people to be machine like and that can easily look like someone is on the spectrum.

replies(3): >>46176552 #>>46180786 #>>46184610 #
4. immibis ◴[] No.46175809[source]
If you think you've explained autism, I invite you to publish a paper.
5. LorenPechtel ◴[] No.46175980[source]
What you read lately is likely derived from Brain Worm's attempts to blame diet for the ills of society. Remember, he doesn't believe in infectious disease, think he gets the rest of it any better?
6. habinero ◴[] No.46176552{3}[source]
Those have the same diagnosis power as "what Hogwarts school are you in" quizzes.

Real assessments are different. Also, ADHD/ASD folks tend to overestimate how universal their experiences and preferences are.

7. MarkMarine ◴[] No.46180786{3}[source]
Didn’t call anyone stupid. I said the comment was stupid. I maintain it was.
8. Nasrudith ◴[] No.46184610{3}[source]
No, I'm afraid the original poster was right. The original comment was just plain stupid. For one there isn't a single 'western diet' any more than there is one 'eastern diet'. If you had attributed a single social issues cause to 'eastern society' like conformity to what you think 'the eastern diet' is and does you'd rightfully be called out for racist stereotyping.
9. tomhow ◴[] No.46187243[source]
Please don't post flamebait like this on HN. It's covered by this guideline:

Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

It's fine to make the point, but it's inevitable that it will stir up strong feelings in others, so it's important to express the point thoughtfully and substantively. In this case, citing credible evidence and being compassionate rather than dismissive, would make a big difference.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

10. tomhow ◴[] No.46187250[source]
Their comment was against the guidelines and I've replied to it to explain how, but it's still not OK to comment like this on HN, no matter what it's in reply to. Please take a moment to remind yourself of the guidelines and make an effort to observe them when participating here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
replies(1): >>46192815 #
11. MarkMarine ◴[] No.46192815{3}[source]
I will Tom. That comment was touching the third rail for me and I reacted where I shouldn’t have.