←back to thread

129 points surprisetalk | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.216s | source
Show context
devmor ◴[] No.45960745[source]
Why does a space engineering lecturer believe he has novel thoughts on ADHD treatment inspired by an author from a medical era he didn’t bother to do cursory research of?
replies(1): >>45973618 #
gishh ◴[] No.45973618[source]
Why does person with $job_title feel like they can write with authority on $subject_not_related_to_job_title?

Is that your question?

replies(1): >>45996016 #
devmor ◴[] No.45996016[source]
No, my question is why someone with a job unrelated to subject didn’t bother to do enough research to find out something as simple as the fact that amphetamines were already used to boost productivity in Huxley’s era before writing as if he had some authority on the subject.

One would think that if you are not an authority in a subject you want to write on, you should do at least the equivalent of a child’s book report research before espousing your opinion and immediately looking like an ass.

replies(1): >>46028313 #
gishh ◴[] No.46028313[source]
Sounds like you have unmet expectations. It’s not really fair to get mad at the author.
replies(1): >>46048964 #
1. devmor ◴[] No.46048964[source]
It is completely fair to expect an author presenting himself as an authority on a subject to have done cursory research on said subject.

The title and premise of the article are a blatant lie.