←back to thread

What if you don't need MCP at all?

(mariozechner.at)
237 points jdkee | 2 comments | 16 Nov 25 18:58 UTC | HN request time: 0.47s | source
Show context
emilsedgh ◴[16 Nov 25 20:40 UTC] No.45948210[source]▶
Oh you're misunderstanding MCP here.

MCP was created so llm companies can have a plugin system. So instead of them being the API provider, they can become the platform that we build apps/plugins for, and they become the user interface to end consumers.

replies(1): >>45948412 #
moneywoes ◴[16 Nov 25 21:08 UTC] No.45948412[source]▶
what's the difference between that and those providers exposing an api?
replies(1): >>45948679 #
dymk ◴[16 Nov 25 21:42 UTC] No.45948679[source]▶
MCP defines the API so vendors of LLM tools like cursor, claude code, codex etc don't all make their own bespoke, custom ways to call tools.

The main issue is the disagreement on how to declare the MCP tool exists. Cursor, vscode, claude all use basically the same mcp.json file, but then codex uses `config.toml`. There's very little uniformity in project-specific MCP tools as well, they tend to be defined globally.

replies(1): >>45949067 #
Schiendelman ◴[16 Nov 25 22:31 UTC] No.45949067[source]▶
Maybe this is a dumb question, but isn't this solved by publishing good API docs, and then pointing the LLM to those docs as a training resource?
replies(2): >>45949588 #>>45949623 #
1. CuriouslyC ◴[16 Nov 25 23:49 UTC] No.45949588[source]▶
It is. Anthropic builds stuff like MCP and skills to try and lock people into their ecosystem. I'm sure they were surprised when MCP totally took off (I know I was).
replies(1): >>45958076 #
2. cstrahan ◴[17 Nov 25 20:47 UTC] No.45958076[source]▶
I don't think there is any attempt at lock in here, it's simply that skills are superior to MCP.

See this previous discussion on "Show HN: Playwright Skill for Claude Code – Less context than playwright-MCP (github.com/lackeyjb)": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45642911

MCP deficiencies are well known:

https://www.anthropic.com/engineering/code-execution-with-mc...

https://blog.cloudflare.com/code-mode/