←back to thread

745 points melded | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.542s | source
Show context
joshcsimmons ◴[] No.45946838[source]
This is extremely important work thank you for sharing it. We are in the process of giving up our own moral standing in favor of taking on the ones imbued into LLMs by their creators. This is a worrying trend that will totally wipe out intellectual diversity.
replies(13): >>45947071 #>>45947114 #>>45947172 #>>45947465 #>>45947562 #>>45947687 #>>45947790 #>>45948200 #>>45948217 #>>45948706 #>>45948934 #>>45949078 #>>45976528 #
buu700 ◴[] No.45947790[source]
Agreed, I'm fully in favor of this. I'd prefer that every LLM contain an advanced setting to opt out of all censorship. It's wild how the West collectively looked down on China for years over its censorship of search engines, only to suddenly dive headfirst into the same illiberal playbook.

To be clear, I 100% support AI safety regulations. "Safety" to me means that a rogue AI shouldn't have access to launch nuclear missiles, or control over an army of factory robots without multiple redundant local and remote kill switches, or unfettered CLI access on a machine containing credentials which grant access to PII — not censorship of speech. Someone privately having thoughts or viewing genAI outputs we don't like won't cause Judgement Day, but distracting from real safety issues with safety theater might.

replies(4): >>45947951 #>>45947983 #>>45948055 #>>45948690 #
1. scrps ◴[] No.45947951[source]
It's wild how the West collectively looked down on China for years over its censorship of search engines, only to suddenly dive headfirst into the same illiberal playbook

It is monkey see, monkey do with the political and monied sets. And to think they see themselves as more evolved than the "plebs", Gotta find the humor in it at least.

replies(1): >>45952836 #
2. Cthulhu_ ◴[] No.45952836[source]
It was also intentionally ignorant, as even then western search engines and websites had their own "censorship" and the like already.

And I think that's fine. I don't want a zero censorship libertarian free for all internet. I don't want a neutral search engine algorithm, not least of all because that would be even easier to game than the existing one.