←back to thread

320 points goldenskye | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
JSR_FDED ◴[] No.45941785[source]
Tariffs are great. They protect the struggling domestic IT industry and gives it time to ramp up its production of vintage computer parts.
replies(14): >>45941811 #>>45941825 #>>45941938 #>>45941960 #>>45942044 #>>45942248 #>>45942306 #>>45942380 #>>45942639 #>>45943114 #>>45943213 #>>45944932 #>>45945406 #>>45948994 #
varispeed ◴[] No.45941825[source]
I know one US business that used to make niche electronic product. Most components they used were from China. Got hit by the tariffs that wiped all the operating profit. Guy also had to sell his home and is now couchsurfing. Business is unlikely going to recover.

Of course he considered making chips and other components in the US, but he was few billions short to start the fab.

replies(6): >>45941829 #>>45941888 #>>45942040 #>>45942090 #>>45942262 #>>45942693 #
calvinmorrison ◴[] No.45942040[source]
a purported niche/low-volume electronics, but the profit is somehow dependent on BOM price? a tariff bump on a small BOM doesn’t take you from profitable to homeless.

if that happened, the business already had seriously bad margins, bad cash flow, over-leverage, or maybe he was just doing it out of love getting paid maybe back for his time or not.

tariffs might’ve hurt, but they don’t collapse a healthy niche hardware company where buyers are presumably also into the niche.

seems weird i dont get it. can you explain further?

replies(3): >>45942272 #>>45942476 #>>45942730 #
esalman ◴[] No.45942476[source]
Do you run a business with good margin, good cash flow, optimally leveraged and for profit? If yes, please tell us more about how tariffs have helped you.
replies(1): >>45943071 #
WalterBright ◴[] No.45943071[source]
If you've been making the products locally, the tariffs on foreign products help you.
replies(3): >>45943285 #>>45943684 #>>45945988 #
esalman ◴[] No.45945988[source]
You cannot truly make anything locally these days. We had decades of free trade. It will take decades to roll back. And you will lose all the benefit that came with it.

Even if we pretend the policies are well-intentioned, it takes decades of investment to make the infrastructure and workforce ready to produce things locally at scale. With policies like the dismantling of department of education, I do not see any initiative being taken to prepare the workforce for the future.

Let's face it, tariffs are a disaster. The increased prices, hurt American businesses, caused job loss, and increased waste and bloat. The administration created a problem (tariff induced inflation), now they are selling the solution by rolling back tariffs to bring prices down. Anybody older than 8 years know this was the same playbook in previous administration. And they know their base is gullible eough to fall for it. It's just unfortunate that hacker news audience in included in there as well.

replies(1): >>45947383 #
WalterBright ◴[] No.45947383[source]
> With policies like the dismantling of department of education, I do not see any initiative being taken to prepare the workforce for the future.

The DOE was created by Carter, and there is no evidence in the last 45 years of it having any positive effect on education in the US.

replies(2): >>45947673 #>>45947929 #
1. samtheprogram ◴[] No.45947673[source]
Indeed, it's directly contributed to burgeoning administrative costs in universities through the Federal Student Loan program, and related the devaluing of college degrees.

It's probably helped in some aspects too, but the student debt crisis was created by the DOE. And most everyone can agree that college costs have ballooned in the US while the value of the degrees have decreased.

It's a perfect example of the worst of both worlds of government guarantees in a capitalist society, like Amtrak and US health care. It eliminates many aspects of competition and blurs incentives while remaining in a economy where decisions are profit-driven.