←back to thread

277 points nharada | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
NullHypothesist ◴[] No.45902077[source]
This is a huge sign of confidence that they think they can do this safely and at scale... Freeways might appear "easy" on the surface, but there are all sorts of long tail edge-cases that make them insanely tricky to do confidently without a driver. This will unlock a lot for them with all of the smaller US cities (where highways are essential) they've announced plans for over the next year or so.
replies(11): >>45902083 #>>45902240 #>>45902312 #>>45902557 #>>45902757 #>>45902766 #>>45902824 #>>45902829 #>>45903817 #>>45904393 #>>45904891 #
embedding-shape ◴[] No.45902557[source]
> Freeways might appear "easy" on the surface, but there are all sorts of long tail edge-cases that make them insanely tricky to do confidently without a driver

Maybe my memory is failing me, but I seem to remember people saying the exact opposite here on HN when Tesla first announced/showed off their "self-driving but not really self-driving" features, saying it'll be very easy to get working on the highways, but then everything else is the tricky stuff.

replies(7): >>45902663 #>>45902725 #>>45902948 #>>45903217 #>>45903507 #>>45904422 #>>45905657 #
xnx ◴[] No.45902725[source]
Highways are on average a much more structured and consistent environment, but every single weird thing (pedestrians, animals, debris, flooding) that occurs on streets also happens on highways. When you're doing as many trips and miles as Waymo, once-in-a-lifetime exceptions happen every day.

On highways the kinetic energy is much greater (Waymo's reaction time is superhuman, but the car can't brake any harder.) and there isn't the option to fail safe (stop in place) like their is on normal roads.

replies(2): >>45903412 #>>45903461 #
1. bryanlarsen ◴[] No.45903412[source]
Those constraints apply to humans too. So it seems likely that:

- it's easier to get to human levels of safety on freeways then on streets

- it's much harder to get to an order of magnitude better than humans on freeways than it is on streets

Freeways are significantly safer than streets when humans are driving, so "as good as humans" may be acceptable there.