←back to thread

71 points dataflow | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
darth_avocado ◴[] No.45777816[source]
Like everyone else who’s observed a discrepancy between how they’re being told the economy is vs how they’re experiencing it, I’ve had my concerns about how CPI is being measured and how the policy decisions are rolled out. One of the things that’s missing is an indicator that cares only about the essentials that are family use frequently. Like falling prices of flatscreen TVs don’t matter as much if home insurance and car payments are skyrocketing.

I came across the ALICE indicator and it does something close to what I wanted. It tells a very different story of how the economy is doing. https://www.unitedforalice.org/essentials-index

replies(5): >>45777861 #>>45777913 #>>45777962 #>>45778073 #>>45778486 #
1. throw0101a ◴[] No.45778073[source]
> One of the things that’s missing is an indicator that cares only about the essentials that are family use frequently. Like falling prices of flatscreen TVs don’t matter as much if home insurance and car payments are skyrocketing.

I think it's useful for people to remember that the numbers reflect averages.

A bunch of surveys are done asking what they spend money on: and the average of those surveys sets the weights for Shelter, Food, Transportation, etc. It's a model, and as the old saying goes:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_models_are_wrong

StatCan (the folks folks that do Canada's CPI) release the "headline number" that all the papers publish in headlines, but in their release they also breakdown what the CPI is for each province (Chart 4), which recognizes the variance of the metric:

* https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/251021/dq251...

StatCan actually also have a page where you can calculate your personal CPI given how much you typically spend on various items:

* https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/71-607-x/71-607-x2020cal...

Perhaps the BLS (or some academic) should release a 'personal CPI' tool as well.