←back to thread

35 points warrenm | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.208s | source
Show context
gef ◴[] No.45771379[source]
I wonder if the British Museum will do the right thing and return previously stolen artefacts?
replies(5): >>45771534 #>>45771633 #>>45771775 #>>45772000 #>>45772937 #
debian3 ◴[] No.45771534[source]
I’m conflicted. I understand the concept that stolen goods should be returned and it’s the right thing to do, but at the same time it was centuries ago and the preservation was done by them. I have seen well preserved exposition in that museum and then you visit the original country where it’s from and they themselves have nothing or very little left from that era.
replies(1): >>45771582 #
jeromegv ◴[] No.45771582[source]
We never fail to find someone to defend colonization!

> then you visit the original country where it’s from and they themselves have nothing or very little left from that era.

You seem to generalize quite a lot in order to validate your view point that everything stolen should stay stolen.

Sometimes it's the entire opposite. It's not being shown anywhere, it's just hidden in a museum collection in the UK. In other cases it's exposed but with very little relevant information because it's not particularly relevant to the local culture or the colonizer is too ashamed of the real history of how this object got there that they fail to explain the true story of it.

Here's a great podcast that I hope will make you change your mind, lots of examples: https://www.cbc.ca/listen/cbc-podcasts/1030-stuff-the-britis...

replies(5): >>45771721 #>>45771828 #>>45771998 #>>45772144 #>>45772386 #
suddenlybananas ◴[] No.45771828[source]
>It's not being shown anywhere, it's just hidden in a museum collection in the UK.

Are you under the impression that the British Museum does not show its Egyptian collections?

>it's not particularly relevant to the local culture

Ancient Egypt also has essentially nothing to do with the culture of most of Egypt, with the exception perhaps of the Copts.

replies(1): >>45775145 #
1. lostlogin ◴[] No.45775145[source]
This argument would be stronger if the Egyptians were displaying Stonehenge and a few long barrows.