←back to thread

917 points cryptophreak | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
andreldm ◴[] No.45761642[source]
If handbrake scares them, don’t you dare to demonstrate how to use ffmpeg. I remember when I used handbrake for the first time and thought “wow, it’s much more convenient than struggling with ffmpeg”.
replies(7): >>45761715 #>>45761913 #>>45761996 #>>45762179 #>>45762626 #>>45762929 #>>45764672 #
MarkusWandel ◴[] No.45761996[source]
At least with ffmpeg, for 99% of use cases you can just google "how do I do X with ffmpeg" and get a copypasta command line.

Whereas with complicated GUI tools, you have to watch a video to learn how to do it.

replies(4): >>45762099 #>>45762129 #>>45762226 #>>45762333 #
xnorswap ◴[] No.45762333[source]
We're going full-circle, because LLMs are amazing for producing just the right incantation of arcane command-line tools. I was struggling to decrypt a file the other day and it whipped me up exactly the right openssl command to get it done.

From which I was able to then say, "Can I have the equivalent source code" and it did that too, from which I was able to spot my mistake in my original attempt. ( The KDF was using md5 not sha ).

I'm willing to bet that LLMs are also just as good at coming up with the right ffmpeg or imagemagick commands with just a vague notion of what is wanted.

Like, can we vignette the video and then add a green alien to the top corner? Sure we can (NB: I've not actually verified the result here) : https://claude.ai/share/5a63c01d-1ba9-458d-bb9d-b722367aea13

replies(1): >>45763167 #
1. 8note ◴[] No.45763167[source]
> I'm willing to bet that LLMs are also just as good at coming up with the right ffmpeg or imagemagick commands with just a vague notion of what is wanted.

they are. ive only used ffmpeg via llm, and its easy to get the LLM to make the right incantation as part of a multi-step workflow.

my own lack of understanding of video formats is still a problem, but getting ffmeg to do the right thing only takes a vague notion