←back to thread

270 points imasl42 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.248s | source
Show context
greymalik ◴[] No.45659146[source]
> One could only wonder why they became a programmer in the first place, given their seeming disinterest in coding.

To solve problems. Coding is the means to an end, not the end itself.

> careful configuration of our editor, tinkering with dot files, and dev environments

That may be fun for you, but it doesn’t add value. It’s accidental complexity that I am happy to delegate.

replies(15): >>45659281 #>>45659294 #>>45659312 #>>45659328 #>>45659361 #>>45659373 #>>45659468 #>>45659961 #>>45660230 #>>45660862 #>>45661685 #>>45663128 #>>45664372 #>>45667053 #>>45676552 #
dingnuts ◴[] No.45659373[source]
A chef who sharpens his knives should stop because it doesn't add value

A contractor who prefers a specific brand of tool is wrong because the tool is a means to an end

This is what you sound like. Just because you don't understand the value of a craftsman picking and maintaining their tools doesn't mean the value isn't real.

replies(1): >>45659845 #
senordevnyc ◴[] No.45659845[source]
Yes, but the point of being a chef is the food, not the knives. If there's a better way to prepare food than a knife, but you refuse to change, are you really a chef? Or are you a chef knife enthusiast?
replies(4): >>45659932 #>>45660275 #>>45660539 #>>45661106 #
codyb ◴[] No.45660275[source]
The point is, a lot of us aren't convinced reviewing 8 meals made by agents in parallel _is_ producing better food.

And it also seems exceedingly wasteful to boot.

replies(1): >>45660519 #
senordevnyc ◴[] No.45660519[source]
I don't think that's really the point of this post; it's all about how LLMs are destroying our craft (ie, "I really like using knives!"), not really about whether the food is better.

I think the real problem is that it's actually increasingly difficult to defend the artisanal "no-AI" approach. I say this as a prior staff-level engineer at a big tech company who has spent the last six months growing my SaaS to ~$100k in ARR, and it never could have happened without AI. I like the kind of coding the OP is talking about too, but ultimately I'm getting paid to solve a problem for my customers. Getting too attached to the knives is missing the point.

replies(2): >>45662341 #>>45687610 #
1. int_19h ◴[] No.45687610[source]
It's both. Speaking as a user, software quality was already declining before AI coding, but AI seems to have put that process on a fast track now (not the least because of all the top management drinking the Kool-Aid and deciding that they can replace the people they have with it).