←back to thread

170 points nimbius | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
stronglikedan ◴[] No.45684922[source]
I feel sorry for the OMIO maintainer community considering how entitled the MinIO community revealed themselves to be.
replies(1): >>45685046 #
Spivak ◴[] No.45685046[source]
Step 1: I made this thing and am freely giving it away for the benefit of everyone. Come join the party!

Step 2: Wow, because this is a community project I can depend on it continuing to exist freely thanks to a large base of diverse parties invested in its continued growth and availability.

Step 3: Just kidding, I'm taking back the thing I made. Sorry if you were depending on it, migrate to something else or pay me.

Step 4: WTF dude?!

Step 5: Why are you all so entitled?

replies(2): >>45685256 #>>45685294 #
ianbutler ◴[] No.45685294[source]
What is so hard about the idea that you are not perpetually entitled to the free labor of other people?

The only thing they owed people here was a 60 day notice imo. That would better respect the social contract.

replies(3): >>45685399 #>>45685455 #>>45685730 #
evilduck ◴[] No.45685730[source]
There was a 60 days notice? https://blog.min.io/

The only notice I have received is from the blowback of their behavior. Walking away from supporting the open source product at any other time than in the wake of a security vulnerability disclosure would have been received better. Sure they're not legally culpable for fixing anything but they're now obviously untrustworthy as a business partner going forwards.

replies(1): >>45685851 #
ianbutler ◴[] No.45685851[source]
Oh then like I don’t even see the problem. That said I think like a direct notification through email or something is probably better than random blog post, but I digress:

They planned to walk away earlier as I believe I saw its really just unfortunate timing.

If you’re doing business with them you should be on a business license with a contract and legal guarantees. I understand it sucks, but it’s a little bit of a self own imo if you’re only on their oss for business purposes. That also kind of breaks the social contract in the opposite direction imo.

replies(1): >>45686251 #
1. 0x457 ◴[] No.45686251[source]
> Oh then like I don’t even see the problem. That said I think like a direct notification through email or something is probably better than random blog post, but I digress:

How would they know your email if you are using minio-oss? Blog post is for sure enough. Decision itself is dumb, it's a public repo with free runners to build images that downloaded 10M times. That behavior is much different how you had to go somewhere else to get OpenJDK binaries.

Maintaining existing build pipeline is nearly zero cost.

replies(1): >>45686921 #
2. ianbutler ◴[] No.45686921[source]
Doesn’t matter it’s not your call.

People should begin to think about these externalities. I do.

If you’re using them for business you should probably have a more formal arrangement where they could email you.