←back to thread

170 points nimbius | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
stronglikedan ◴[] No.45684922[source]
I feel sorry for the OMIO maintainer community considering how entitled the MinIO community revealed themselves to be.
replies(1): >>45685046 #
Spivak ◴[] No.45685046[source]
Step 1: I made this thing and am freely giving it away for the benefit of everyone. Come join the party!

Step 2: Wow, because this is a community project I can depend on it continuing to exist freely thanks to a large base of diverse parties invested in its continued growth and availability.

Step 3: Just kidding, I'm taking back the thing I made. Sorry if you were depending on it, migrate to something else or pay me.

Step 4: WTF dude?!

Step 5: Why are you all so entitled?

replies(2): >>45685256 #>>45685294 #
ianbutler ◴[] No.45685294[source]
What is so hard about the idea that you are not perpetually entitled to the free labor of other people?

The only thing they owed people here was a 60 day notice imo. That would better respect the social contract.

replies(3): >>45685399 #>>45685455 #>>45685730 #
Spivak ◴[] No.45685399{3}[source]
I'm not. If they had simply said, "Hey this is getting to be too much work and I don't want to continue anymore. Let me know if you're interested in taking over maintainership of the project." then that's fine. Hell even if they just archived the project and ghosted never to be seen again that's also fine.

It's (yet another) example of a company donning the trappings of an open source project as a "growth hack" or to secure VC funding and then rug pulling when they decide they want to try and squeeze their user base for cash. They're the corporate stooges that insert themselves into high-trust communities and subcultures to make a buck and ruin it for everyone.

replies(1): >>45685728 #
1. ianbutler ◴[] No.45685728{4}[source]
I mean is it though? They've been open source for over a decade thats a really long con I guess.

It’s more likely circumstances have changed. Which is why forking is a thing and you dont have to be oss forever.

I stand by my assertion that this would have been fine if they didn’t communicate like garbage. They should have said what you said and gave a good off ramp period.