←back to thread

How do we stop AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images?

(redasadki.me)
14 points redasadki | 3 comments | 23 Oct 25 16:33 UTC | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
redasadki ◴[23 Oct 25 16:33 UTC] No.45683864[source]▶
Researchers like Arsenii Alenichev are correctly identifying a new wave of “poverty porn 2.0,” where artificial intelligence is used to generate stereotypical, racialized images of suffering—the very tropes many of us have worked for decades to banish.

The alarms are valid.

The images are harmful.

But I am deeply concerned that in our rush to condemn the new technology, we are misdiagnosing the cause.

The problem is not the tool.

The problem is the user.

replies(2): >>45683946 #>>45684348 #
1. PaulHoule ◴[23 Oct 25 16:40 UTC] No.45683946[source]▶
The NGO-industrial complex?

https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2019/jun/12/o...

replies(1): >>45684148 #
2. redasadki ◴[23 Oct 25 16:57 UTC] No.45684148[source]▶
Yeah, of course. But that's the imperfect best we've been able to do as societies to respond to the needs of the most vulnerable. Unless you think we should just let people die when there is a disaster or a catastrophe that is overwhelming?
replies(2): >>45684308 #>>45684930 #
3. PaulHoule ◴[23 Oct 25 18:09 UTC] No.45684930[source]▶
We've seen a hollowing out of the state in the core under neoliberalism which on one hand is out-and-out austerity and the other half is the inability to execute which Ezra Klein talks about it.

In the same time period we've seen donor organizations like the Gates Foundation pursue a model where NGOs pick and choose a few state functions that they'd like to take over in the periphery. This bypassing of the state gets things done in the short term but in the long term it doesn't help countries develop the state capacity to do things themselves.

My radical proposal is that third world countries develop and tax their economy to provide the services that their people want and that those governments should be accountable to those people. However the NGO-industrial complex is part of the same tendency that erodes state capacity in both the core and periphery.

Structurally the problem at hand won't go away unless NGOs get past the model of showing people poverty porn to make them donate or believe in the legitimacy of the NGO. In the end they could send a photographer out to a refugee camp to make very similar images that are real and if you think those fake images are harmful the real images are too.