1. Immich hosts user content on their domain. And should thus be on the public suffic list.
2. When users host an open source self hosted project like immich, jellyfin, etc. on their own domain it gets flagged as phishing because it looks an awful lot like the publicly hosted version, but it's on a different domain, and possibly a domain that might look suspicious to someone unfamiliar with the project, because it includes the name of the software in the domain. Something like immich.example.com.
The first one is fairly straightforward to deal with, if you know about the public suffix list. I don't know of a good solution for the second though.
I get that SPAM, etc., are an issue, but, like f* google-chrome, I want to browse the web, not some carefully curated list of sites some giant tech company has chosen.
A) you shouldn't be using google-chrome at all B) Firefox should definitely not be using that list either C) if you are going to have a "safe sites" list, that should definitely be a non-profit running that, not an automated robot working for a large probably-evil company...
It's browser beware when you do, but you can do it.
The problem is that at least some of the people maintaining this list seem to be a little trigger happy. And I definitely thing Google probably isn't the best custodian of such a list, as they have obvious conflicts of interest.
People are reacting as if this list is some kind of overbearing way of tracking what people do on the web - it's almost the opposite of that. It's worth clarifying this is just a suffix list for user-hosted content. It's neither a list of user-hosted domains nor a list of safe websites generally - it's just suffixes for a very small specific use-case: a company providing subdomains. You can think of this as a registry of domain sub-letters.
For instance:
- GitHub.io is on the list but GitHub.com is not - GitHub.com is still considered safe
- I self-host an immich instance on my own domain name - my immich instance isn't flagged & I don't need to add anything to the list because I fully own the domain.
The specific instance is just for Immich themselves who fully own "immich.cloud" but sublet subdomains under it to users.
> *if you are going to have a "safe sites" list"
This is not a safe sites list! This is not even a sites list at all - suffixes are not sites. This also isn't even a "safe" list - in fact it's really a "dangerous" list for browsers & various tooling to effectively segregate security & privacy contexts.
Google is flagging the Immich domain not because it's missing from the safe list but because it has legitimate dangers & it's missing from the dangerous list that informs web clients of said dangers so they can handle them appropriately.