Most active commenters
  • forgotmypw17(5)
  • tonymet(3)

←back to thread

582 points SweetSoftPillow | 13 comments | | HN request time: 2.497s | source | bottom
1. forgotmypw17 ◴[] No.45670627[source]
I've come up with an easy solution, which works almost all the time. When a cookie consent dialog interferes with me using the website, I close the tab and move on.

I've found a high correlation between cookie consent notices and low-signal content, so this strategy has actually saved me a lot of time I would've spent reading/watching something that doesn't help me.

replies(1): >>45670878 #
2. tonymet ◴[] No.45670878[source]
How do you book airline tickets? Ir other critical business ? My doctors office has a cookie banner . Should I just stop going ?
replies(2): >>45671127 #>>45671373 #
3. hahn-kev ◴[] No.45671127[source]
Yeah I agree, that sentiment works if you only consume content online. But for real stuff? Good luck
4. forgotmypw17 ◴[] No.45671373[source]
That's why I said "almost all of the time".

But to the flights example, I was just looking for flights starting at Google Flights, which doesn't have cookie banners, and the two sites I went to for booking also did not have cookie banners.

replies(3): >>45671573 #>>45673164 #>>45675381 #
5. SpicyLemonZest ◴[] No.45671573{3}[source]
Which booking website are you going to that doesn't have cookie banners? I spot checked multiple EU and US airlines just now (Ryanair, Air France, United, Alaska) and all of them had a cookie banner.
replies(1): >>45672664 #
6. forgotmypw17 ◴[] No.45672664{4}[source]
I started with Google Flights and went to two other sites that it directed me to.

Just to reiterate, I'm not religious about this practice. If I need to click a cookie banner to book a plane ticket, so be it.

I just treat cookie banners as a strong negative signal.

7. macbr ◴[] No.45673164{3}[source]
Google, including Google Flights, does have a cookie banner. It's just likely that you already accepted/denied the prompt at some point.
replies(1): >>45673518 #
8. forgotmypw17 ◴[] No.45673518{4}[source]
That’s certainly possible. I don’t deny occasionally clicking them. I just don’t bother most of the time.

Edit: I just tried the flight ordering flow again (starting at google.com/flights) in a private/incognito tab, and did not encounter any cookie banners.

9. tonymet ◴[] No.45675381{3}[source]
any site with a cart or user prefs should have a cookie disclosure
replies(2): >>45675477 #>>45676297 #
10. freehorse ◴[] No.45675477{4}[source]
Not all cookie banner implementations are obstructive to the users. Only the ones that really want you click on "accept all" are.
11. forgotmypw17 ◴[] No.45676297{4}[source]
This is not true, cookie disclosure is only required for non-essential cookies.
replies(1): >>45678153 #
12. tonymet ◴[] No.45678153{5}[source]
Well they need to track the above activities
replies(1): >>45678945 #
13. tikotus ◴[] No.45678945{6}[source]
Yes, they are essential. Therefore no permission needed for those.