←back to thread

672 points LexSiga | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
mattbee ◴[] No.45667259[source]
They abandoned documentation (edit: for the open source codebase) a couple of weeks ago - that seems more significant.

From their Slack on Oct 10:

"The documentation sites at docs.min.io/community have been pulled of this morning and will redirect to the equivalent AIStor documentation where possible". [emphasis mine]

The minio/docs repository hasn't been updated in 2 weeks now, and the implication is that isn't going to be.

Even when I set up a minio cluster this February, it was both impressively easy and hard in a few small aspects. The most crucial installation tips - around 100Gb networking, Linux kernel tunables and fault-finding - were hung off comments on their github, talking about files that were deleted from the repository years ago.

I've built a cluster for a client that's being expanded to ≈100PB this year. The price of support comes in at at slightly less than the equivalent amount of S3 storage (not including the actual hosting costs!). The value of it just isn't that high to my client - so I guess we're just coasting on what we can get now, and will have to see what real community might form around the source.

I'm not a free software die-hard so I'm grateful for the work minio have put into the world, and the business it's enabling. But it seems super-clear they're stopping those contributions, and I'd bet the final open source release will happen in the next year.

If anyone else is hosting with minio & can't afford the support either :) please drop me a line and maybe we can get something going.

replies(6): >>45668446 #>>45668529 #>>45668617 #>>45670374 #>>45670759 #>>45672247 #
Joker_vD ◴[] No.45668446[source]
Nah, it's fine. It's Open Source, you can document it yourself if you need to! But there is no obligation from the MinIO authors to provide it, you're not entitled to it.
replies(1): >>45669893 #
1. MrDarcy ◴[] No.45669893[source]
It sounds like you’re being sarcastic but what you say is correct and true.
replies(1): >>45671247 #
2. danudey ◴[] No.45671247[source]
It can be correct and true while at the same time being bad-faith and user-hostile.
replies(1): >>45676272 #
3. MrDarcy ◴[] No.45676272[source]
I’m a firm believer in open source and have decades of experience with it as an active community member.

There are two sides to this coin and tension in between.

On the one side license change rug pulls are annoying and deserve negative consequences.

On the other side, open source users are often far too entitled and demanding, contributing little and taking much.

At the end of the day the license terms are clear and users would do well to expect no more than the license says they’re entitled to expect.

Maybe then everyone can start being pleasantly surprised by each other’s behavior instead of both sides being disappointed by the other.