←back to thread

674 points peterkshultz | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
brosco ◴[] No.45636152[source]
I have a tip for following lectures (or any technical talk, really) that I've been meaning to write about for a while.

As you follow along with the speaker, try to predict what they will say next. These can be either local or global predictions. Guess what they will write next, or what will be on the next slide. With some practice (and exposure to the subject area) you can usually get it right. Also try to keep track of how things fit into the big picture. For example in a math class, there may be a big theorem that they're working towards using lots of smaller lemmas. How will it all come together?

When you get it right, it will feel like you are figuring out the material on your own, rather than having it explained to you. This is the most important part.

If you can manage to stay one step ahead of the lecturer, it will keep you way more engaged than trying to write everything down. Writing puts you one step behind what the speaker is saying. Because of this, I usually don't take any notes at all. It obviously works better when lecture notes are made available, but you can always look at the textbook.

People often assume that I have read the material or otherwise prepared for lectures, seminars, etc., because of how closely I follow what the speaker is saying. But really most talks are quite logical, and if you stay engaged it's easy to follow along. The key is to not zone out or break your concentration, and I find this method helps me immensely.

replies(14): >>45636222 #>>45636706 #>>45636714 #>>45637096 #>>45637126 #>>45637135 #>>45637344 #>>45637810 #>>45637939 #>>45638250 #>>45638369 #>>45638918 #>>45638928 #>>45643170 #
whatever1 ◴[] No.45637810[source]
Which is why I hate the PowerPoint presentation-based lectures. Speaker typically goes too fast, and their brain does not actually break down the arguments into logical steps. They just read the slides.

Chalk and board is the way.

replies(3): >>45639909 #>>45640286 #>>45640510 #
baq ◴[] No.45640510[source]
Reading from slides is the absolute worst way of delivery anywhere, whether it’s a lecture or an internal presentation to your work team, doesn’t matter. The best power point slides have zero overlapping words with what the presenter is saying except perhaps some slide or section titles.

Chalk and board though is not necessarily the best. Power point supports magic hotkeys - B and W - and allows drawing on slides. When done properly with a stylus, it’s incrementally better in almost every way than chalk, though a proper lecture hall with multiple blackboards will still hold its own.

replies(2): >>45643220 #>>45664398 #
1. rlexsu ◴[] No.45664398[source]
Although I would prefer the slides having no overlapping words, but doing it this way is very punishing for whoever that skip the class for whatever reason.

Looking at the slides no longer build enough context for you to learn and catchup on what you have missed, so in the end every lecture is unskippable.