←back to thread

ChatGPT Atlas

(chatgpt.com)
763 points easton | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0.467s | source | bottom
1. tekacs ◴[] No.45663810[source]
One thing that I would watch out for with _all_ OpenAI products is that they use Keychain's Access Control lists to encrypt data such that _you_ cannot unlock or access it.

It's a change that they made to 'fix' this issue: https://pvieito.com/2024/07/chatgpt-unprotected-conversation...

The net effect however is that if you use their apps, you can get data _in_, but you can only get it _out_ in ways that their apps themselves allow. The actual encryption of Chrome data seems to be _potentially_ held behind the 'ChatGPT Safe Storage' key that - since it's Chromium - you can unlock (for now), but the rest of Atlas's keys do the same thing as the above - locking you out of the encrypted data on your own computer.

I understand the rationale that it protects the data from malware or users willingly filling in a password dialogue, but the current approach means that any _intentional_ access by other apps or automated backups or export (even with Full Disk Access or similar) can't see into the apps' data.

More context: https://chatgpt.com/share/68f82df3-74f0-8012-9bfe-de89a4e75e...

replies(4): >>45663851 #>>45664815 #>>45667839 #>>45668249 #
2. SahAssar ◴[] No.45663851[source]
> More context: https://chatgpt.com/share/68f82df3-74f0-8012-9bfe-de89a4e75e...

Are you using chatgpt to factcheck what chatgpt does on your computer?

replies(2): >>45669956 #>>45671275 #
3. rafram ◴[] No.45664815[source]
You: “Has someone got a good way of getting my chats out of ChatGPT, whether on web or through the desktop app, perhaps as an MCP?”

ChatGPT: “Treat MCP as “Multi-Chat Package” (zip/tar of Markdown along with a manifest).

Is this the PhD-level AI we were promised?

4. ◴[] No.45667839[source]
5. 3form ◴[] No.45668249[source]
I see that mobile brainrot is starting to set in.

TPM requirement will make this kind of a thing on PCs a regular occurrence.

6. xd1936 ◴[] No.45669956[source]
We have conducted a thorough internal review and have concluded that we committed no wrongdoing.
7. tekacs ◴[] No.45671275[source]
I... am using it to have it indict itself, yes?