←back to thread

425 points karimf | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
miki123211 ◴[] No.45656279[source]
> Try asking any of them “Am I speaking in a low voice or a high voice?” in a high-pitched voice, and they won’t be able to tell you.

I wonder how much of that is LLMs being bad, and how much is LLMs being (over) aligned not to do it.

AFAIK, Chat GPT Voice mode had to have a lot of safeguards put on it to prevent music generation, accent matching (if you sound Indian, it shouldn't also sound Indian), and assuming ethnicity / biasing based on accents.

It doesn't seem that impossible to me that some of these behaviors have been aligned out of these models out of an abundance of caution.

replies(7): >>45656408 #>>45656467 #>>45656667 #>>45657021 #>>45657291 #>>45658995 #>>45665432 #
idonotknowwhy ◴[] No.45656467[source]
Qwen3 omni transcriber can do this. It can describe the voice, emotion very well
replies(1): >>45657007 #
1. 85392_school ◴[] No.45657007[source]
I've also had luck with Gemini. If I made a few noises and asked which one was higher pitched, it could easily tell.