←back to thread

349 points zdw | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
foxglacier ◴[] No.45652693[source]
I wonder why the old advice was being given if it was so wrong? If nobody understood what to do, shouldn't there have been no advice instead of something harmful?
replies(9): >>45652756 #>>45652763 #>>45652768 #>>45652807 #>>45652849 #>>45652903 #>>45653509 #>>45653756 #>>45671594 #
alex_young ◴[] No.45652756[source]
If people are developing allergies to food, isn’t a logical first step to not expose babies to the allergens? It seems logical. It turns out to be exactly backwards.
replies(1): >>45652816 #
rmunn ◴[] No.45652816[source]
It would seem logical, until you learn what allergies are. They are the body's immune system overreacting to something that would normally be harmless, and acting as if it's an invading pathogen. Once you learn that, then realizing "hey, expose the body to this thing early on, and the body's immune system will treat it as normal" is a logical step.

If this theory (that early exposure teaches the immune system not to overreact) is right, then another logical consequence would be that kids who play outside in their early years would have fewer pollen allergies than kids who mostly play indoors and are exposed to far less pollen than the outdoors-playing kids. I don't know where to look for studies to prove or disprove that thesis; anyone have any pointers?

replies(3): >>45652866 #>>45652882 #>>45652886 #
1. renewiltord ◴[] No.45652886{3}[source]
Well, I mean, did you know that skin exposure can sensitize and oral exposure builds tolerance? I certainly didn’t. That’s a subtlety of the exposure game that I did not know.

E.g. from age 27 weeks my daughter has played in a little herb garden full of mud and grass I built for her. She grabs and eats leaves from the herb plants (the basil is entirely denuded so that’s a complete loss). At first I just wanted her to play in the garden out of the same naïve exposure to tolerance model. I never would have considered that skin exposure is different from oral exposure. As it so happened she ate the plant leaves and it doesn’t matter either way since this part of immunity (to microbes here) doesn’t work in the same way as peanuts anyway.