←back to thread

Android's sideloading limits are its most anti-consumer move

(www.makeuseof.com)
627 points josephcsible | 1 comments | 13 Oct 25 15:24 UTC | HN request time: 0.235s | source
Show context
itg ◴[13 Oct 25 16:13 UTC] No.45570037[source]▶
Installing any app I want outside the Play Store was the primary reason I decided to go with Android, despite most of the people I know using iPhones. If I can't do this anymore, I may as well switch and be able to use iMessage and FaceTime with them.
replies(20): >>45570221 #>>45570261 #>>45570265 #>>45570587 #>>45570668 #>>45572259 #>>45572346 #>>45573245 #>>45573688 #>>45573719 #>>45573848 #>>45573983 #>>45574065 #>>45574119 #>>45574318 #>>45574480 #>>45575073 #>>45575074 #>>45575317 #>>45575483 #
jadbox ◴[13 Oct 25 16:29 UTC] No.45570261[source]▶
You can still install apps outside the play store, but the developer does need to verify their signing information. Effectively this means that any app you install must have a paper trail to the originating developer, even if its not on the app store. On one hand, I can see the need for this to track down virus creators, but on the other, it provides Google transparency and control over side loaded app. It IS a concerning move, but currently this is far from 'killing' non-appstore apps for most of the market.
replies(10): >>45570571 #>>45570633 #>>45570634 #>>45570683 #>>45571257 #>>45571700 #>>45572133 #>>45572345 #>>45573858 #>>45574064 #
omnimus ◴[13 Oct 25 16:57 UTC] No.45570633[source]▶
Yeah... no. This is normal with desktop computers. Let's stop handholding people. If I trust the source, I trust the domain... I want to be able to install app from its source.

Googles/Apples argument would have been much stronger if their stores managed to not allow scams/malware/bad apps to their store but this is not the case. They want to have the full control without having the full responsibility. It's just powergrab.

replies(2): >>45571729 #>>45572271 #
raw_anon_1111 ◴[13 Oct 25 18:27 UTC] No.45571729[source]▶
And you are completely ignoring viruses, ransomware, keyloggers, the 50 toolbars etc that has been the staple of Windows and before that DOS for over 40 years.

Scam apps are rife in the iOS App Store. But what they can’t do easily install viruses that affect anything out of its sandbox, keyloggers, etc

replies(3): >>45571935 #>>45572108 #>>45572592 #
xigoi ◴[13 Oct 25 19:05 UTC] No.45572108[source]▶
The toolbars don’t just magically appear there. They are the product of a technically illiterate user.
replies(1): >>45572421 #
raw_anon_1111 ◴[13 Oct 25 19:34 UTC] No.45572421[source]▶
Yes because technically literate users shouldn’t have trusted mainstream companies to not install bundle ware back in the Day? They shouldn’t have trusted Zoom not to install a web server on Macs surreptitiously that caused a vulnerability? They shouldn’t have searched Google for printer drivers not knowing that it was a fake printer driver? They shouldn’t have trusted Facebook when they installed VPN software that tracked all of their traffic from any app?

Is that really your answer? To make the phone ecosystem as fraught as Windows PCs for the average user? How is they worked out for PC users since the 80s?

replies(2): >>45573852 #>>45573959 #
orangecat ◴[13 Oct 25 22:08 UTC] No.45573852[source]▶
How is they worked out for PC users since the 80s?

Just to be clear, are you claiming that we would be better off if PC hardware and OS vendors had the level of control that smartphone vendors do today?

replies(1): >>45573966 #
raw_anon_1111 ◴[13 Oct 25 22:21 UTC] No.45573966[source]▶
For almost every user - yes. If apps had to run in a strict sandbox it would be better for most users. Where it would make you jump through an incredible number of hoops or even install “developer editions” of operating systems.

You really can’t trust developers to do the right thing - even major developers like Zoom (the secret web server) , Facebook (the VPN that trashed usage actoss apps on iOS) and Google (convincing consumers to install corporate certificates to track usages on iOS).

Even more to the point, you read about some app installed outside of the Google Play store that’s malware - including the official side loaded version of FortNite…

https://blog.checkpoint.com/research/fortnite-vulnerability-...

replies(1): >>45574945 #
orangecat ◴[14 Oct 25 00:40 UTC] No.45574945[source]▶
I appreciate your response even though I strongly disagree.

You really can’t trust developers to do the right thing

Indeed not, and that includes OS developers. Imagine if Microsoft had been able to block web browsers other than IE in the name of "security".

replies(1): >>45574989 #
1. raw_anon_1111 ◴[14 Oct 25 00:49 UTC] No.45574989[source]▶
Well, you have to trust the operating system vendor.