←back to thread

185 points ivewonyoung | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
agentcoops ◴[] No.45409472[source]
There's an ambiguity in the title, reflected in some comments below. It can be understood either as the claim that "in a particular human being, to be intelligent as measured by IQ means that you are more likely to be autistic", suggesting for example a trade-off between social and general intelligence; or the claim that "the evolution of the human brain and so human intelligence as such, which characterizes both those of low and high IQ, entailed those genetic shifts that made autism a possibility for our species but not other primates." The paper argues a form of the latter.
replies(5): >>45409754 #>>45409793 #>>45410064 #>>45410925 #>>45412115 #
nkozyra ◴[] No.45410064[source]
> in a particular human being, to be intelligent as measured by IQ means that you are more likely to be autistic

I find this part to be a really strong highlight of our change in perception of autism and what it means to be "autistic" or "on the spectrum."

Perhaps due to the broadening of the spectrum or just an odd association with success and spectrum attributes, we now strongly associate intelligence with spectrum. Historically - perhaps due to a narrower definition of autism - the inverse was true. It's understood now to not have much strong correlation with IQ at all, but apply fairly distributed in a way similar to general population, certainly not skewed one way or the other in a strong way.

[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9058071/

replies(1): >>45412555 #
hyghjiyhu ◴[] No.45412555[source]
I still think it's odd how aspergers disappeared as a label. Made more sense than a spectrum with both really smart people and really stupid ones.
replies(3): >>45412907 #>>45416932 #>>45427177 #
1. seec ◴[] No.45427177{3}[source]
It's not very odd. It's all part of the drift of science, where now things are loosely defined and what passes for science is often political propaganda.

The removal of Aspergers label has a lot more do to with politics (not wanting to be associate with nazi) than anything else.

As far I'm concerned, the only hope is from genetics studies, which greatly accelerated thanks to computing. At some point with enough studies, we will know what's what. In the meantime, it is safe to discard most of the bullshit coming from psychological studies...