←back to thread

287 points jonbruner | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
Neywiny ◴[] No.45366921[source]
I find their table of advertised vs actual capacity to be misleadingly negative. They only discharged to 3v. 2.7 could be viewed as more standard. 2.5 is not unheard of. For example, the vapvell 4000 they said was around 3000. They even have a note that says that isn't a reasonable capacity estimate. And yet they still put the percentage and the number. As if they've falsely advertised. However, if you go to vapcell's graphs on their website, it all tracks. Feels out of scope for the report and shouldn't have been done
replies(3): >>45368052 #>>45370289 #>>45391469 #
quickthrowman ◴[] No.45391469[source]
How do you even drain a 3.7V lithium ion battery below 3.3V? My devices that use 18650s will not let them go below that. Is it 3.3V nominal and the actual voltage is lower, like how they’re 4.2V fully charged?
replies(3): >>45391820 #>>45392775 #>>45394350 #
joecool1029 ◴[] No.45391820[source]
I guess leave them sitting in a laptop in a barn for a few years. I was given some old shit gateway the other day, tried to charge it, no dice. Ripped the pack apart to find samsung 18650's with approx 0.7V voltage.

Against ALL recommendations I put these cells into a MC3000 and they charged up just fine to 4.2V. It does a 0.15A charge per cell until it gets above 3V. Then I had it set to 1.92A bulk charge. Fire extinguisher nearby lol

replies(1): >>45392791 #
privatelypublic ◴[] No.45392791[source]
Can't recommend charging cells that have fallen below their official stop voltage- the liability and risk is too high. However, numerous papers have shown that the serious risks happen if they're reverse charged.

I wouldn't use anything but a bench supply stuck outside though.

replies(1): >>45398113 #
1. joecool1029 ◴[] No.45398113[source]
As I said, it's against all recommendations. I've done this a few times over the years though and haven't hit the copper shunting problem described in literature. If they did have that problem my charger would pick up the short and stop charging them.

I did have a failure once and it was on a new molicel. I damaged the outside wrap of a cell while building a pack and it had a short and self-discharged the cell, likely reverse charging it in use. A week or so later the charger rejected it. When I pulled it out it was a fully shorted cell that would accept no charge, but it did not catch fire.