←back to thread

525 points alex77456 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
voidUpdate ◴[] No.45386876[source]
What's the benefit of this over a passport? A passport is a physical thing, so you don't need to have a phone to be able to use it, proves who you are with the same details as this digital ID, and will probably require a similar amount of paperwork to get hold of
replies(5): >>45386882 #>>45387014 #>>45387018 #>>45387253 #>>45387370 #
lightwords ◴[] No.45387014[source]
You usually don't want to carry a passport with you at all times. In some European countries (e.g., the Nordics), you have your ID, driver’s license, firearm license, etc., all in a government app that can be verified with an app used by officials. You can also sign and authenticate all paperwork with the same system
replies(3): >>45387025 #>>45387083 #>>45387099 #
matt-p ◴[] No.45387025[source]
Good for them, but I don't see why we need this, or indeed why that's a good thing?
replies(1): >>45387094 #
netdevphoenix ◴[] No.45387094[source]
Easy and cheap regular checks on the spot presential or/and online, as frequently as you want vs rare scheduled difficult and expensive checks.

Possibilities get realised such as regular remote checks (ie selfie to prove you are the id owner holder, address proof, etc, flagging odd id holder behaviour or employer, etc). Currently, you cannot do this, no visibility into who works where and where that person even resembles the person meant to be working for [insert gig company].

replies(2): >>45387226 #>>45387250 #
matt-p ◴[] No.45387226[source]
I do selfie to prove I match my driver's license all the time (needed for app based banks, and so on)?

The government absolutely knows where I work, are you joking? That's what NI numbers are for. You seriously think there isn't a join table in a government database with my NI number and passport number?

replies(1): >>45387339 #
netdevphoenix ◴[] No.45387339[source]
There are other workers in the UK aside from you. The policy affects them too not just you. You are getting the business requirements wrong. You are unlikely to be the main reason for the policy. Folks getting paid under minimum wage such as some gig workers using someone else's identity are the main target.
replies(1): >>45387510 #
matt-p ◴[] No.45387510[source]
If they arrived here legally won't they have a passport? Or national photo ID at the very least? If they are driving for Uber or deliveroo then they'll have a driver's license too? If they don't have either (or a UK birth certificate) then it's safe to say they're not a legit citizen?

Who exactly are we solving for?

replies(1): >>45387630 #
netdevphoenix ◴[] No.45387630[source]
> If they arrived here legally won't they have a passport? Or national photo ID at the very least? If they are driving for Uber or deliveroo then they'll have a driver's license too? If they don't have either (or a UK birth certificate) then it's safe to say they're not a legit citizen?

Simple. Overstaying or/and expired passport will lead to that. Valid status is not a fixed binary state. It is better described as a function of personal id, rights docs and current time. Currently, the checks are more akin to updating a Boolean column on rare occasions. Digital id countries do checks more like function calls that you can perform easily and quickly

replies(1): >>45387753 #
1. matt-p ◴[] No.45387753{3}[source]
RTW already requires ID plus NI, but OK what about if we just said 'free passports' and then said passport or driving licence plus NI is needed to get a job here. If you have a foreign passport and no UK driving licence then yes you'll have to keep that up to date in order to work here, c'est la vie.