←back to thread

525 points alex77456 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
jjgreen ◴[] No.45385121[source]
Before the election I was approached by a bubbly young woman who tried to persuade me to vote Labour: "No thanks, last time I did that they tried to introduce ID cards", "But that's not in our manifesto" she replied, "It wasn't the last time I voted for them either".

It gives me no pleasure to be right on this.

replies(3): >>45385315 #>>45389860 #>>45390373 #
celticninja ◴[] No.45385315[source]
Could you explain what it is you find so distasteful about ID cards?

I mean if you have a passport then you already have an 'ID card', but I certainly don't want to take that out with me to prove my age.

replies(7): >>45385353 #>>45385512 #>>45385524 #>>45387406 #>>45390224 #>>45391030 #>>45391103 #
jjgreen ◴[] No.45385353[source]
Could you please give me your real name "celticninja", your phone number, your address, your NI number -- oh, and you'll need to install this app on your phone which I promise will never be used to monitor your location, purchases, friends. Then I'll explain.
replies(4): >>45385433 #>>45385455 #>>45385574 #>>45389857 #
tpxl ◴[] No.45385574[source]
> Could you please give me your real name "celticninja", your phone number, your address, your NI number

The police can and will request this information from you, digital ID or not. If you have actual beef with digital ID, present it.

replies(3): >>45385624 #>>45385650 #>>45389524 #
1. mytailorisrich ◴[] No.45385624{3}[source]
No, police cannot.

The government is pushing Digital IDs on rubbish claims (obviously won't do anything about illegal immigration). Everyone can see that.

So what does this mean about their actual aims?