←back to thread

525 points alex77456 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.226s | source
Show context
remarkEon ◴[] No.45382398[source]
>The proposals are the government's latest bid to tackle illegal immigration, with the new ID being a form of proof of a citizen's right to live and work in the UK.

How does a digital ID solve an illegal immigration problem? I watched the video and the suggestion is that this makes it easier for employers to verify that someone is authorized to work. Is that actually true? I don't live in the UK and have not visited in several years. If the idea is that a digital ID authorizes employment ... well I hope people can see the problem, here.

replies(17): >>45382454 #>>45382455 #>>45382475 #>>45382616 #>>45382656 #>>45382769 #>>45382795 #>>45382859 #>>45382864 #>>45382925 #>>45383460 #>>45383814 #>>45383976 #>>45384100 #>>45384475 #>>45391178 #>>45394684 #
JumpCrisscross ◴[] No.45382769[source]
> How does a digital ID solve an illegal immigration problem?

It's presumably harder to forge a cryptographic signature than paper documents? Not saying it's a good tradeoff. But executed competently, it makes sense in theory.

replies(3): >>45383072 #>>45383154 #>>45384037 #
logifail ◴[] No.45383154[source]
> It's presumably harder to forge a cryptographic signature than paper documents?

Unless there is both serious pressure from the state and the population at large supports a massive increase in checking and being checked I struggle to see this working.

During the pandemic various countries experimented with mandating showing of QR codes to do stuff to "prove" compliance ... yet looking back on that, all it seems to have done is accelerate the erosion of trust in politicians and systems of government :/

replies(1): >>45383630 #
incone123 ◴[] No.45383630[source]
Checking for right to work has been legally required for over a decade. Checks in the formal economy are now routine. Can sometimes be a nuisance, like for my friend who doesn't have a passport and his driving license was issued before those went photographic.
replies(1): >>45383708 #
1. logifail ◴[] No.45383708[source]
> Checks in the formal economy are now routine

Someone who is prepared to pay people smugglers to help them cross a border illegally may not choose to restrict themselves to working in "the formal economy".

"Illegal working and streams of taxis - BBC gains rare access inside asylum hotels"

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwy8ee2w73jo