←back to thread

525 points alex77456 | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
remarkEon ◴[] No.45382398[source]
>The proposals are the government's latest bid to tackle illegal immigration, with the new ID being a form of proof of a citizen's right to live and work in the UK.

How does a digital ID solve an illegal immigration problem? I watched the video and the suggestion is that this makes it easier for employers to verify that someone is authorized to work. Is that actually true? I don't live in the UK and have not visited in several years. If the idea is that a digital ID authorizes employment ... well I hope people can see the problem, here.

replies(17): >>45382454 #>>45382455 #>>45382475 #>>45382616 #>>45382656 #>>45382769 #>>45382795 #>>45382859 #>>45382864 #>>45382925 #>>45383460 #>>45383814 #>>45383976 #>>45384100 #>>45384475 #>>45391178 #>>45394684 #
Insanity ◴[] No.45382454[source]
In all fairness, the “immigration” story is likely just a convenient spin on a more realistic goal of state surveillance on it’s own citizens.
replies(3): >>45382583 #>>45383434 #>>45384055 #
Nursie ◴[] No.45382583[source]
While there is almost guaranteed to be an aspect of this, the UK is going through a period where immigration is in the news constantly and the populist party "Reform UK" are on the rise.

The Labour government has realised that whatever their own feelings are about people coming to the UK by irregular means and claiming asylum, they need to be seen to recognise the popular narrative right now that the boats must be stopped, and be seen to be taking action.

So I don't think the immediate state goal right here is likely to be anything deeper than desperately trying to head off Nigel Farage, who is capturing a lot of public discourse about this 'crisis'.

replies(3): >>45383028 #>>45383341 #>>45383454 #
gmac ◴[] No.45383341[source]
… except that trying to out-Farage Farage (by being bastards to asylum seekers) will lose them many of their traditional supporters (who are not big on being bastards to asylum seekers) and seems unlikely to gain them many Farage supporters (why would they take some half-hearted populist bastardry when they can have the real deal?).

The ‘small boats’ narrative is ludicrously over-reported here. It’s such a clear case of those with most of the resources scapegoating those with none of the resources as the cause of everyone else’s problems.

replies(3): >>45383513 #>>45383535 #>>45383762 #
1. padjo ◴[] No.45383535[source]
It’s amazing to see Labour fall for the same trick that the Tories did with Brexit, and also incredible that Farage is still a political force after all the Brexit lies.
replies(2): >>45389881 #>>45394237 #
2. card_zero ◴[] No.45389881[source]
That's not a trick, it's how third parties have influence in a two-party system: the two main parties are compelled to steal any popular policy from a third party before it becomes a credible threat.
3. whackernews ◴[] No.45394237[source]
What Brexit lies?
replies(1): >>45394564 #
4. padjo ◴[] No.45394564[source]
350m for the NHS.