←back to thread

118 points venkii | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.002s | source
Show context
mahrain ◴[] No.45343382[source]
I have worked on such systems at Signify: There are numerous barriers to wider adoption except for very high risk situations. For instance: there have yet to be lawsuits to determine the risk of exposing people to UV. As you see in the comments below, any "UV" is considered dangerous by people not aware of the biological effects of various wavelenghts.

Besides this, excimer lamps have a low expected lifetime, of both the light source as well as the filter due to the high energy in the UV photons. This makes replacement (and maintenance cost) a real risk. This could be remedied by similar wavelength LEDs from companies like CrystalIS but these are expensive and very low power (only work germicidal on a short distance).

Prof. Brenner at Columbia University has first foreseen applications of 222nm in operating rooms, to prevent infection during surgery.

On the whole, it would need significant investment in both research, certification and risk analysis for this to become commercially viable, so while some of the technology is there, the market demand so far just is not -- post-pandemic.

replies(4): >>45343507 #>>45343550 #>>45344311 #>>45345213 #
unsnap_biceps ◴[] No.45343507[source]
Every year our HVAC company tries to sell us UV lights for the HVAC system. They claim it's only about $1500 to install. Are these snake oil?
replies(5): >>45343540 #>>45344906 #>>45345566 #>>45349837 #>>45350036 #
mahrain ◴[] No.45343540[source]
Mostly used to eliminate or reduce mould growth on the inverter? If HVAC is taking air in or blowing air out, there really wouldn't be a point disinfecting the air.

If it's re-circulating, it could reduce the spread of germs room to room as has been shown during the pandemic in elderly care facilities. That would be the only use-case I see.

replies(1): >>45343549 #
1. unsnap_biceps ◴[] No.45343549[source]
they claim it would reduce growths on the coils but also eliminate mold and bacteria spores. Our system is a re-circulating system. One large intake in the center of the house and out flows in individual rooms.
replies(1): >>45343634 #
2. mahrain ◴[] No.45343634[source]
The mould reduction is real, and could lenghten the maintenance intervals for cleaning. Not fully eliminate it though, it really only eliminates the parts the UV light reaches (so not the back, or any other part not exposed).