←back to thread

152 points Gaishan | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.202s | source
Show context
V__ ◴[] No.45340359[source]
> Conventional research papers require readers to invest substantial effort to understand and adapt a paper's code, data, and methods to their own work [...]

But that's the point! If we take out the effort to understand, really understand something on a deeper level from even research, then how can there be anything useful build on top of it? Is everything going to loose any depth and become shallow?

replies(6): >>45340411 #>>45341919 #>>45342900 #>>45343183 #>>45343438 #>>45343442 #
1. zaptheimpaler ◴[] No.45343183[source]
Easy to say but have you ever read a paper and then a summary or breakdown of that paper by an actual person? Or compare a paper that you do understand very well with how you would explain it in a blog post.

The academic style of writing is almost purposefully as obtuse and dense and devoid of context as possible. Academia is trapped in all kinds of stupid norms.