←back to thread

192 points imasl42 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
rsynnott ◴[] No.45311963[source]
This idea that you can get good results from a bad process as long as you have good quality control seems… dubious, to say the least. “Sure, it’ll produce endless broken nonsense, but as long as someone is checking, it’s fine.” This, generally, doesn’t really work. You see people _try_ it in industry a bit; have a process which produces a high rate of failures, catch them in QA, rework (the US car industry used to be notorious for this). I don’t know of any case where it has really worked out.

Imagine that your boss came to you, the tech lead of a small team, and said “okay, instead of having five competent people, your team will now have 25 complete idiots. We expect that their random flailing will sometimes produce stuff that kinda works, and it will be your job to review it all.” Now, you would, of course, think that your boss had gone crazy. No-one would expect this to produce good results. But somehow, stick ‘AI’ on this scenario, and a lot of people start to think “hey, maybe that could work.”

replies(21): >>45312004 #>>45312107 #>>45312114 #>>45312162 #>>45312253 #>>45312382 #>>45312761 #>>45312937 #>>45313024 #>>45313048 #>>45313151 #>>45313284 #>>45313721 #>>45316157 #>>45317467 #>>45317732 #>>45319692 #>>45321588 #>>45322932 #>>45326919 #>>45329123 #
nkmnz ◴[] No.45312114[source]
> This idea that you can get good results from a bad process

This idea is called "evolution"...

> as long as you have good quality control

...and it's QA is death on every single level of the systems: cell, organism, species, and ecosystem. You must consider that those devs or companies with not-good-enough QA will end up dead (from a business perspective).

replies(3): >>45313261 #>>45317009 #>>45323798 #
1. rsynnott ◴[] No.45323798[source]
I look forward to software which takes several million years to produce and tends to die of Software Cancer.

Like, evolution is not _good_ at ‘designing’ things.