←back to thread

335 points coloneltcb | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.204s | source
Show context
ayaros ◴[] No.45302728[source]
I guess things could be worse? The Internet Archive is too precious of a resource for humanity to lose. I still fear its days are numbered. I don't think non-technical people appreciate it, or are even aware of its existence, in the same way as Wikipedia.
replies(3): >>45302913 #>>45307789 #>>45312618 #
miki123211 ◴[] No.45302913[source]
I'm a technical person, and not a fan of copyright by any means, and I don't appreaciate it either.

To be clear, I appreciate the concept of an "Internet Archive", but the current organization / execution / management is absolutely atrocious.

replies(7): >>45303323 #>>45307010 #>>45307620 #>>45307868 #>>45307897 #>>45308857 #>>45309838 #
8bitsrule ◴[] No.45308857[source]
Also Not A Fan. Consider that nearly all of the artists who made records pressed on 78 shellacs are long gone. How specious is the claim that they are even a significant revenue stream for the majors? (The purported rationale for copyright.)

Suppose it were significant; then how many of the artists' descendents are getting their share of the streaming revenues on those copyrighted trax? (Before the copyright expires, of course.)

Another specious claim of the majors: these trax are 'still out there'. All 400,000? How would you know, and how would anyone where to look? If you can find where they're hiding, one at a time (online or in a cardboard box under a table in the back of a record store in Poughkeepsie?) Here they all are, on one library's website.

The Great 78 collection is a wonderful and delightful addition to the historians and explorers of 42 genres of music. It's the sort of contribution only a Great Library could afford to make. Of course, beyond the comprehension of mere commerce.

replies(1): >>45312470 #
1. badlibrarian ◴[] No.45312470[source]
Review the Music Modernization Act (2018) which allows anyone to send a list of pre-1972 recordings to the Copyright Office. If no entity responds saying they are making commercial use of those recordings, the recordings become Free for non-commercial use, including unlimited download. Now consider why Brewster gave talks celebrating this law but chose not to follow it.