←back to thread

1311 points mriguy | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.222s | source
Show context
guyzero ◴[] No.45306779[source]
Everyone in these threads always points out all sorts of issues with the H1B system, which are mostly true, but it's not like there's a suggestion for a replacement here. This is a de facto shutdown of the program, not a reform. I'd be happy to see a reformed skilled immigration program for the US, but this isn't it.

The US makes up about 4.5% of the global population and it seems silly to think that the FAANG companies and the new AI startups chasing behind them are going to restrict their hiring to this tiny slice of the global talent pool.

The only effect this is going to have is accelerating the offshoring of jobs through more hiring in India, Europe and Canada, which is a net loss for the US.

I myself became a US citizen two years ago after being on a H1B. I was paid the same as all my peers and for all its shortcomings the program worked for me. It stunning to think this has been closed off, killing the main path for skilled immigration into the US.

replies(9): >>45306924 #>>45307136 #>>45307319 #>>45307323 #>>45307343 #>>45308114 #>>45308830 #>>45310714 #>>45313601 #
callc ◴[] No.45308114[source]
> The only effect this is going to have is accelerating the offshoring of jobs through more hiring in India, Europe and Canada, which is a net loss for the US.

I’m honestly tired of hearing the argument “if we do X then business will move to another state or out of US”.

Good riddance to the companies that flee from jurisdictions enforcing workers rights, don’t allow exploitation, etc.

The most important thing is protecting people, not fearing the cries of money-making machines.

replies(4): >>45308231 #>>45309514 #>>45309989 #>>45313004 #
spacebanana7 ◴[] No.45308231[source]
Particularly in tech, where the network effects and first mover advantages are so strong.

California could introduce a million dollar minimum wage for software engineers, ban electricity on Thursdays, raise corporate taxes to 60% and still probably have more new unicorns founded in the subsequent year than Europe.

replies(2): >>45308968 #>>45309793 #
mavelikara ◴[] No.45309793[source]
Subsequent year, probably. In later years, no. Massachusetts is case study on this.
replies(1): >>45311235 #
cowsandmilk ◴[] No.45311235[source]
What happened in Massachusetts?
replies(1): >>45311726 #
1. anon7725 ◴[] No.45311726[source]
Seems like the point is what’s not happening there