←back to thread

1308 points mriguy | 5 comments | | HN request time: 1.037s | source
Show context
ChicagoDave ◴[] No.45306865[source]
This will only drive jobs offshore and reduce the H1B population. It doesn’t solve any problems.

This is literally the dumbest administration this country has ever seen. Between tariffs and immigration and now this, it’s like they don’t even know what the consequences of their actions are.

replies(1): >>45307303 #
1. TMWNN ◴[] No.45307303[source]
>This will only drive jobs offshore

This was true before and after today.

Put another way, if all the H-1B jobs really can be offshored quickly and easily the way so many Indians and anti-Trump people here and elsewhere confidently predict, *that would have happened already*.

replies(2): >>45310215 #>>45310636 #
2. ChicagoDave ◴[] No.45310636[source]
There’s a fundamental difference in talent. H1b talent is often upper class scions from India or China. Offshore talent has always been leveraged for support or staff aug.

It’s entirely possible some H1b’s would happily pay the $100k if they had a guaranteed visa for 5-10+ years, but the vast majority will simply go home and work remotely.

But I believe the effect of this extortion will be a brain drain on U.S. fortune 1000 companies and that will push those same companies to build off shore offices, completely avoiding the administration’s goofiness.

3. krmboya ◴[] No.45310654[source]
The H1B path has always been harder than hiring remotely/offshoring
replies(1): >>45310822 #
4. donkeybeer ◴[] No.45310822{3}[source]
And now making it even harder will encourage more of the latter. Which of course you can try tariffing.
replies(1): >>45310840 #
5. N2yhWNXQN3k9 ◴[] No.45310840{4}[source]
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/excisetax.asp

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/tariff.asp