←back to thread

291 points mooreds | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.223s | source
Show context
pixelpoet ◴[] No.45291451[source]
> one of the only

That reminds me, I still have to put up the explanation at oneoftheonly.com for why this phrase doesn't make sense and is the new "could care less".

replies(9): >>45291462 #>>45291488 #>>45291513 #>>45291551 #>>45291558 #>>45291634 #>>45291684 #>>45291917 #>>45292615 #
1. shayway ◴[] No.45291634[source]
It makes sense both grammatically and logically; I think this might just be a parsing issue.

For example: Alaska and Hawaii are the only non-contiguous U.S. states. Alaska is one of the only non-contiguous states.

The 'only' is part of the group definition, implying the individual 'one' is part of a small subset of some sort.