←back to thread

Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year

(skyfall.dev)
2071 points JustSkyfall | 1 comments | 18 Sep 25 01:37 UTC | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
p0w3n3d ◴[18 Sep 25 05:20 UTC] No.45285730[source]▶
We're using teams in my new company, which is awful for textual communication (lacks threads in chats, groups are more like old forums than new IM). I've been experimenting with self-hosted Mattermost but it seems that it also requires paid license in some situations (e.g. does not have groups for some reason in the free version).

I was unable to find another system. Would anyone recommend me something?

replies(7): >>45285747 #>>45285847 #>>45285925 #>>45287053 #>>45287610 #>>45287668 #>>45287976 #
jwrallie ◴[18 Sep 25 05:37 UTC] No.45285847[source]▶
I was considering moving from Slack (free version) to Teams (paid) for a new project starting in October because my workplace already have a license for that. Seems like it will have less features but no 90 day retention annoyances.

You seem to have some experience with both, do you think I am making a bad decision for a ~30 person team?

Others suggested Matrix, but I have a feeling they are implicitly assuming self-hosting. I do think Element works quite well, but I have only used it personally with matrix.org for basic chat, never for work. It does work on both Android and iOS as well as Linux, which is why I use it.

replies(5): >>45285889 #>>45286074 #>>45286098 #>>45286215 #>>45286624 #
1. p0w3n3d ◴[18 Sep 25 06:15 UTC] No.45286098[source]▶
I'd been working for 4 years with slack, and now for 5 months with teams. Slack was easier searchable, thread organisation is much better. In teams there are two types of communication - one is chat which has no threads (just answer to message as in WhatsApp), and channels which has forum vibe (more like post board).

Calls are better in teams, much better to be precise than slack. We rarely used slack for calls (it had nice feature of drawing on colleague's screen) which I think is also available in teams.

I think that integration is crippled in teams but I didn't have time to experiment with it.

So overall I'd suggest: go for teams if you want to call meetings and are not using slack as a main knowledge base, as we used to in my previous company. Especially considering matters highlighted in this article