←back to thread

1332 points Qem | 10 comments | | HN request time: 1s | source | bottom
Show context
random9749832[dead post] ◴[] No.45267646[source]
[flagged]
dotancohen[dead post] ◴[] No.45267975[source]
[flagged]
1. random9749832 ◴[] No.45268197[source]
Intentionally killing children will never be justified, everything else serves as a decoy from acknowledging this simple fact.
replies(2): >>45268230 #>>45268237 #
2. bsaul ◴[] No.45268230[source]
Nobody in israel's army is aiming at children except maybe for some people turning crazy because of the war, which happens in every war.

Pretending otherwise is just blatant propaganda.

3. dotancohen ◴[] No.45268237[source]
Israel does not intentionally kill children. Hamas does. They state it clearly.
replies(3): >>45268406 #>>45268440 #>>45270999 #
4. lentil_soup ◴[] No.45268406[source]
Quite a few thousand killed by Israel, or are you claiming that's not true?
replies(3): >>45268598 #>>45268600 #>>45268963 #
5. adhamsalama ◴[] No.45268440[source]
Quite the opposite actually.

You're free to Google the countless cases of Israel deliberately killing children, but I doubt you wanna get out of your echo chamber.

replies(1): >>45268616 #
6. SilverElfin ◴[] No.45268598{3}[source]
I wouldn’t call those intentional. Collateral damage in a defensive war against terrorists who are hiding among civilians is different from intentionally seeking to kill children as your only objective.
7. dotancohen ◴[] No.45268600{3}[source]
I agree that thousands of children have been killed in Gaza - by both Israel and Hamas. Trying to pin all of them on Israel only encourages Hamas to kill more.
8. dotancohen ◴[] No.45268616{3}[source]
My echo chamber? I read the Gazan and other Arab telegram channels in Arabic. I write back and forth with people in Gaza (Gazans, who live there) every few days. You levy at me unfounded accusations.
9. GoatInGrey ◴[] No.45268963{3}[source]
Even if Israel is definitively shown to be genocidal, what the hell do you do with that? Because the result of that determination is that you now have a conflict where both sides are genocidal against the other. How do you pick a side in that scenario without implicitly supporting genocide? Do you try to determine whether Palestinian lives are worth more or less than Israeli/Jewish lives, using your own arithmetic? Try to argue that some forms of genocide aren't really genocide when you "really think about it"?

I think it's an impossible problem from an ethics perspective.

10. ◴[] No.45270999[source]