←back to thread

1332 points Qem | 6 comments | | HN request time: 0.966s | source | bottom
Show context
Invictus0[dead post] ◴[] No.45267813[source]
[flagged]
1. nemomarx ◴[] No.45267904[source]
What stat are you using for current Palestinian population during this conflict? Any good estimate of the deaths to hunger over the next few years?

I don't believe that the charges in the report require success either way, but it would help with your statistics.

replies(1): >>45268733 #
2. machina_ex_deus ◴[] No.45268733[source]
Even according to Hamas own numbers, 60,000 Palestinians died, 200 from starvation. That's very low compared to real genocides. That's very low considering Israel killed an estimated 10,000 of Hamas soldiers. That's pretty good accuracy in all modern standards of war.
replies(2): >>45268948 #>>45269839 #
3. bjourne ◴[] No.45268948[source]
According to Wikipedia between 25 and 33 thousand Bosnians and Croats were killed in the Bosnian genocide. Thus your argument doesn't hold, unless you contend that there was no genocide in Bosnia either.
4. jcranmer ◴[] No.45269839[source]
A 1:6 ratio for civilian deaths is not a good civilian casualty ratio by the standards of modern warfare. Russia in Ukraine is currently achieving a rate of about 1:3, and that's a country that's currently considered rather brutal as far as civilian casualty rates go. The US in the Iraq War managed urban operations with kill ratios better than 1:1.
replies(2): >>45271261 #>>45272095 #
5. Invictus0 ◴[] No.45271261{3}[source]
Have you seen how small and remote the villages are where Russia and Ukraine are fighting? Gaza is one of the most densely populated areas on earth and the fighters are not wearing uniforms and are directly embedded in civilian population centers.
6. _DeadFred_ ◴[] No.45272095{3}[source]
What is the number in Mariupol ? A hell of a lot higher than 1:3.