←back to thread

1041 points mpweiher | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
m101 ◴[] No.45230060[source]
I think a good exercise for the reader is to reflect on why they were ever against nuclear power in the first place. Nuclear power was always the greenest, most climate friendly, safest, cheapest (save for what we do to ourselves), most energy dense, most long lasting, option.
replies(25): >>45230185 #>>45230223 #>>45230479 #>>45230658 #>>45230757 #>>45231144 #>>45231518 #>>45231738 #>>45232518 #>>45232615 #>>45232756 #>>45232757 #>>45232937 #>>45233169 #>>45233513 #>>45233762 #>>45233817 #>>45233825 #>>45234181 #>>45234637 #>>45234828 #>>45235394 #>>45238856 #>>45240108 #>>45243016 #
jerome-jh ◴[] No.45232937[source]
From the top of my head, for about 300 nuclear power plants around the globe, there have been 3 core meltdown accidents. It is a 1% catastrophic failure rate. It is quite bad!

Whatever the circumstances of these accidents, human nature and unexpected events allowed them to occur. Just like every accident, you can say after the fact they could have been avoided. However it is impossible to revert the consequences of a core meltdown at human time scale.

I am not anti-nuclear at all. But I certainly wonder what kind of organization is required to operate it safely.

replies(2): >>45233217 #>>45233992 #
adastra22 ◴[] No.45233217[source]
Meanwhile coal power alone is causing 60 deaths per day (20k per year). And that’s a conservative NIH number, not a biased nuclear industry estimate.

3 meltdowns in the past 60 years with minimal loss of life (even including Chernobyl, an outlier for so many reasons), is a massively safer alternative than the status quo.

replies(1): >>45233633 #
nilslindemann ◴[] No.45233633{3}[source]
See my brown bear vs car comparison above/below.

Also, solar causes less deaths, according to your counting method.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldw...

replies(3): >>45233986 #>>45234371 #>>45236432 #
mensetmanusman ◴[] No.45233986{4}[source]
https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy

Analogy doesn’t work, it’s deaths per TWhour that matter.

replies(1): >>45234132 #
1. ◴[] No.45234132{5}[source]