←back to thread

1041 points mpweiher | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
Luker88 ◴[] No.45230034[source]
I am not sure people understand the implications of this.

First, it's not just nuclear, it's also Natural gas.

Second, lots of nations have incentives for "clean" energy. And now magically, all those incentives apply to nuclear and gas.

It's a money grab from nuclear and gas manufacturers. It's not that the courts were involved for nothing.

Still, we should use more nuclear. If only it was less expensive to build...

replies(5): >>45230176 #>>45231995 #>>45232405 #>>45232913 #>>45233455 #
m101 ◴[] No.45230176[source]
Nuclear + gas is the climate friendly solution.
replies(4): >>45230204 #>>45230313 #>>45230789 #>>45232360 #
grafmax ◴[] No.45230789[source]
Gas isn’t climate friendly just because of its debatable attractiveness vs coal. And nuclear comes with catastrophic risks that require large costs to mitigate. Let’s not pretend it’s some panacea. Renewables are better than both.
replies(2): >>45230801 #>>45232366 #
mpweiher ◴[] No.45230801[source]
Fun fact: The US achieved more for the climate with fracking gas than Germany did with its "Energiewende".
replies(1): >>45230940 #
kla-s ◴[] No.45230940[source]
Do you care to explain more, id be interested :)
replies(1): >>45231025 #
mpweiher ◴[] No.45231025[source]
In 2005, both the US and Germany had specific emissions of around 600g CO₂/kWh.

In 2015, due mostly to fracking gas, the US was down to around 450g CO₂/kWh.

Germany, with its Energiewende, was at around 560g CO₂/kWh.

Because, of course, the Energiewende was not about climate change. It was about shutting down climate-friendly (CO₂ free) nuclear plants.

Both could have done better. France is currently at something like 32g CO₂/kWh and has been at roughly that level for decades.

replies(2): >>45231070 #>>45231146 #
oneshtein ◴[] No.45231146{3}[source]
In 2024, US was at 384 gCO₂/kWh, while Germany was at 344 gCO₂/kWh.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/carbon-intensity-electric...

replies(1): >>45231202 #
1. mpweiher ◴[] No.45231202{4}[source]
The US fracking boom lasted until about 2015.

And according to energycharts.de Germany was at 395g CO₂/kWh in 2023.

Again, both pale in compare to France.