←back to thread

271 points pykello | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.206s | source
Show context
CursedSilicon ◴[] No.45172165[source]
I'm a staunch defender of OpenWRT. Having used just about every "router distro" folks care to name (remember SmoothWall?) for the last 20~ years, OpenWRT is built like a tank and just keeps trundling along

I hope their experiments with the "OpenWRT One" keep going. I'd love to see OpenWRT take a (deserved) bite out of the "SMB firewall vendors" like Netgate or OPNsense. Or just undercutting Wi-Fi vendors like Ubiquiti who base their work on OpenWRT anyway

Something I'm excited to try myself in future is running "OpenWISP" [1] to manage a small fleet (three) OpenWRT devices in parallel for a deployment in a shared workshop. This seems to also be something that OpenWRT could be better at integrating, but it's nice to see "a vendor" tackling it

[1] https://openwisp.org/

replies(13): >>45172279 #>>45172309 #>>45172531 #>>45172754 #>>45172784 #>>45173737 #>>45174002 #>>45174350 #>>45175850 #>>45175928 #>>45176717 #>>45177390 #>>45177963 #
tw04 ◴[] No.45175928[source]
>I'd love to see OpenWRT take a (deserved) bite out of the "SMB firewall vendors" like Netgate or OPNsense. Or just undercutting Wi-Fi vendors like Ubiquiti who base their work on OpenWRT anyway

Why? You don't want competition in the space?

>Or just undercutting Wi-Fi vendors like Ubiquiti who base their work on OpenWRT anyway

Huh? The older edgerouters were based on vyatta. The newer ones on a custom linux distro, neither of which are OpenWRT. They hired the original author of pfsense to build them a firewall based on Debian from scratch when they realized vyatta wasn't going to meet their needs. The UDM kernel is very much not OpenWRT

https://github.com/fabianishere/udm-kernel

Being excited about OpenWRT is great but spreading bad information and for reasons I can't fathom hoping for the downfall of other players in the market, not so much.

replies(1): >>45176027 #
1. gonzopancho ◴[] No.45176027[source]
> They hired the original author of pfsense to build them a firewall based on Debian from scratch when they realized vyatta wasn't going to meet their needs. The UDM kernel is very much not OpenWRT

You're (perhaps unintentionally) also spreading bad information here.

The original 'author' of pfSense was Scott Ullrich, not Chris Buechler. While they were partners in the project, Scott was technical, and Chris did a lot of work back then on documentation, by by his own admission back then, "I am not a developer", and this, even though he was CTO.

http://freesoftwaremagazine.com/articles/interview_with_jeff...

Ubiquiti originally hired two of the devs out of Vyatta to maintain their fork of the Vyatta codebase. These two were known on the Ubiquiti forum as 'stig' and 'An Chen'. Both left in the first half of 2016, and then (and only then) did Ubiquiti hire Chris Buechler, in an attempt to maintain and extend the Ubiquiti firmware. Chris has since left Ubiquiti and is now at Alta Labs.