←back to thread

560 points whatsupdog | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.203s | source
Show context
perihelions ◴[] No.45167153[source]
Hard-earned freedoms are wasted on societies who don't have memories of what it took to earn them. Freedom is a ratchet: slides easily and frictionlessly one way, and offers immense resistance in the other.

This is all so disheartening.

replies(8): >>45167266 #>>45167299 #>>45167311 #>>45167395 #>>45167428 #>>45167827 #>>45168737 #>>45169148 #
cedws ◴[] No.45167299[source]
I’m not aware of a single nation where the ratchet is loosening. It appears freedom is being eroded everywhere. The most disheartening thing is that nothing works to stop it. There are countries where millions of people have protested, but in time the protests always fizzle or are stamped out, and things continue on the same trajectory.
replies(9): >>45167349 #>>45167367 #>>45167482 #>>45167497 #>>45167525 #>>45168365 #>>45168793 #>>45170031 #>>45170789 #
1. martin-t ◴[] No.45168365[source]
You can't make people care.

Not by telling them they should care. They have to experience. Unfortunately, with dictatorship, once you are experiencing it, it's already too late.

---

The reasons democracies slide towards less freedom is that in theory decisions should be made by people who care and are informed. But in reality, a single vote every few years is too imprecise to express any kind of informed opinion.

You pick and issue, do research and vote according to what's best for you and/or society. Except you can't vote on the issue. You vote for a party or candidate which also has stances towards dozens other issues. So even if you provide signal in one dimension, you provide only noise in others.

Voting for parties/candidates is like expressing your entire opinion, a multidimensional vector, by picking one point from a small number of predefined choices.