←back to thread

560 points whatsupdog | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.324s | source
Show context
netsharc ◴[] No.45167080[source]
So where's the donkey and where's the cart.

It reads like: citizens have been protesting the government using social media, government desperate to curb dissent bans social media, dissent is now on the streets..

Or maybe it's as straightforward as the media has been reporting.

replies(3): >>45167140 #>>45167146 #>>45167160 #
seer ◴[] No.45167160[source]
Just a random tourist caught up in all of this in Nepal right now, but what I gathered was that corruption and anti-government sentiment was the reason, but the social networks ban tipped people over the edge to start protesting.
replies(1): >>45167265 #
mothballed ◴[] No.45167265[source]
Nepal government made the classic mistake of not realizing if you let people scream into the ether on whatever the youth use as twitter, they won't meet up with their friends to scream on the street or even worse.
replies(3): >>45167335 #>>45167392 #>>45167522 #
BoxFour ◴[] No.45167392[source]
Social media has proven to be quite an effective tool for mobilizing protests and beyond. I get how the short-sighted might see it as a tactical move to "cripple logistics" by banning social media.

But, the reason I call it short-sighted is exactly what you said: Removing those earlier pressure-release valves doesn’t solve the underlying issue at all and just increases the risk of a more volatile outcome.

replies(1): >>45167643 #
1. JumpCrisscross ◴[] No.45167643[source]
> Social media has proven to be quite an effective tool for mobilizing protests

Gatherings, yes. Effective protest, I’m less convinced.

Effective protests “have clear strategic goals, use protest to broaden coalitions, seek to enlist more powerful individuals in their cause, and connect expressions of discontent to broader political and electoral mobilization” [1].

Social media helps enlist the elite. But it absolutely trashes clarity of goals and coalition broadening, often degrading into no true Scotsman contests. If a protest is well planned, social media can help it organize. But if a movement is developing, social media will as often keep it in a leaderless, undisciplined and thus ineffective state.

[1] https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-power-of-protest-in-t...