←back to thread

115 points cdipaolo | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
ashray ◴[] No.45160149[source]
This was already the case for almost every other country. Most embassies required you to be resident or a national of the country you are applying in.

So oddly, the US was far more permissive than other locales in this one aspect. All this change does is bring it in line with security practices that other nations already had in place.

Honestly am quite surprised that the US didn’t already have this restriction considering overall it’s one of the toughest countries to get a visa for or even enter with a valid visa.

The US visa vetting procedure is known to be so strict even for tourists that many nations give visa free access to nationals who would otherwise require a visa - just because they hold a valid (or sometimes even expired!) US visa. It’s a highly regarded sticker if you can get one in your passport and seriously ups the power of your passport if it’s a weaker one to start with.

replies(3): >>45160247 #>>45160519 #>>45164675 #
abxyz ◴[] No.45160247[source]
Really? Do you have any examples? I’ve had visas around the world (and encountered numerous weird requirements) but never have I been required to apply for a visa from my country of nationality. Even China, which is very restrictive, allows for non-national applications.

(And in fact, in my experience, it is getting easier with online applications becoming more common.)

replies(3): >>45160318 #>>45160341 #>>45160478 #
throw-the-towel ◴[] No.45160341[source]
Schengen works exactly like this. Also Japan I think.
replies(2): >>45160471 #>>45161277 #
the_mitsuhiko ◴[] No.45161277[source]
Schengen does not work like that. While you are supposed to apply from the country you are a resident in, if you have valid reasons you can apply from any other country. This is also frequently necessary (eg: traveller without fixed residence).
replies(1): >>45161918 #
throw-the-towel ◴[] No.45161918{3}[source]
Well, just happening to be in a different country is not a "valid reason". Maybe for someone from the West it would be accepted, but not for the rest of us.

Also, "a traveler without a fixed residence" can get a non-immigrant visa for Schengen? I'm sorry but this just is not true if you're not a Westerner.

replies(1): >>45162033 #
1. the_mitsuhiko ◴[] No.45162033{4}[source]
> Also, "a traveler without a fixed residence" can get a non-immigrant visa for Schengen? I'm sorry but this just is not true if you're not a Westerner.

If there is no doubt that you will leave and you can sustain yourself: sure.

replies(1): >>45162239 #
2. throw-the-towel ◴[] No.45162239[source]
Being abroad is already a huge challenge to proving you're going to leave. You're showing you don't have much tethering you to your country of origin.